AQABA| A RESILIENT CITY THROUGH ITS NEIGHBORHOODS Friedrich Ebert Stiftung | AE Business Council| November 2021 Prepared by Mohammad Alshafie Hadeel Ayed Omar Dahabreh Ahmad Elayan Nashwa Suboh Firas Sweidan Hazem Zureiqat The Regional Energy and Climate Project in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) of Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung has Funded, commissioned, edited, and reviewed this study. Published by A/E Business Council. Year 2021 Not for sale. All Rights Reserved. No Part of this publication may be printed, reproduced, or utilized in any form or by any means without prior written permission from publishers. The views and opinions expressed in this publication are solely those of the original author. He does not necessarily represent those of the Friedrich-EbertStiftung or the editor. The Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan The Deposit Number at The National Library (6697/11/2021) 624.0956534 Aqaba: A Resilient City Through Its Neighborhoods/ Mohammad Suliman AL-Shafie...[etc.al].-Amman:A/E Business Council, 2021 (101) p. Deposit No.: 2021/11/6697 Descriptors: /Civil Engineering//Structural Engineering//Aqaba(Jordan)/ ةبتكملا ةرئاد يأر نع فنصملا اذه ربعي الو هفنصم ىوتحم نع ةينوناقلا ةيلوؤسملا لماك فلؤملا لمحتي .ىرخأ ةيموكح ةهج يأ وأ ةينطولا AQABA| A RESILIENT CITY THROUGH ITS NEIGHBORHOODS Authors Mohammad Alshafie Hadeel Ayed Omar Dahabreh Ahmad Elayan Nashwa Suboh Firas Sweidan Hazem Zureiqat Graphic Design Hadeel Ayed Omar Dahabreh Contributors Sara Alawad Saifeddin Al Belbeisi Rana Al-Khatib Audai Hassouna Farah Zumot ISBN NO.: 978-9923-9893-1-9 PREFACE This study examines Aqaba’s resiliency and sustainability through its neighborhoods. Hence, it analyzes the current situation and challenges that were brought to light during the pandemic as well as envisioning long-term strategies. Using the transition management approach and showcasing several neighborhoods, the analysis focuses on environmental, planning, and mobility issues along with community engagement challenges. Based on the thorough analyses, a set of possible short- and long-term components are suggested to create sustainable and resilient neighborhoods that are equipped to deal with any future crisis. The study is a result of a dynamic collaboration between multiple parties who collectively composed an intensive study of Aqaba’s neighborhoods and came up with proposed solutions to address the pressing issues at hand. A/E BUSINESS COUNCIL The A/E Business Council is a membership and representational association offering professional services to architecture and engineering consulting companies based in the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan. Its principal objectives are to promote quality, excellence, and competitive standards in the sector; and to facilitate trade through best practices both in Jordan and in overseas export markets. The A/E Business Council is a not-for-profit association that supports its members through networking, consultation with government agencies concerning professional and regulatory issues, information sourcing, business training and education, and the promotion of international trading links. The A/E Business Council is supported by, and works closely, with the Jordan Engineers Association(JEA), and the Engineering Offices Committee(EOC) through continuous dialogue and joint committees. FRIEDRICH EBERT STIFTUNG FES is a German non-profit political foundation based on the principles of social democracy. It was founded in 1925 to promote international cooperation, education, and research in Germany and abroad. The activities of FES Amman focuses on promoting social democracy, sustainable economic growth, political participation, social justice, and gender equality as well as contributing to peace and security in the region and ecological sustainability through the Regional Climate& Energy Project. The Regional Climate and Energy Project MENA advocates for an energy transition into renewable energy and energy efficiency. It continues to search for just transition solutions in the energy sector that ensure both, the protection of the planet and the people. As the MENA region is one of the most affected areas by climate change, we contribute to policy advising, research, and advocacy in the areas of climate change policy, energy transition, and urban sustainability, with the support of research institutions, civil society organizations, and other partners in the region and in Europe. CONTENTS 01 INTRODUCTION............................................... 4 1.1 Objective of the Study........................................... 5 1.2 Impact of COVID-19.............................................. 6 1.3 Characteristics of Urban Resilience........................ 7 02 THE CITY OF AQABA: AN OVERVIEW............. 10 2.1 Urban Planning in Aqaba....................................... 11 2.2 Mobility in Aqaba.................................................. 12 2.3 Environment in Aqaba........................................... 13 2.4 Community Inclusion in Aqaba.............................. 17 03 APPROACH& METHODOLOGY..................... 18 3.1 Transition Management................................................. 19 3.2 Methodology......................................................... 20 3.3 Implementing Transition Management.................. 21 3.4 Focusing on Neighborhoods................................. 22 3.4.1 Focus Neighborhoods Selection Criteria...... 23 04 ANALYZING SELECTED NEIGHBORHOODS.... 24 4.1 Selected Neighborhoods Analysis Criteria............ 25 4.2 Pilot Neighborhood A- District 10........................ 26 4.3 Pilot Neighborhood B- District 7.......................... 38 4.4 Community Inclusion Workshop............................ 50 4.5 Framing Challenges............................................... 56 05 DESIGN& PLANNING SOLUTIONS................ 57 5.1 Recommendations................................................. 58 5.1.1 Neighborhood Planning Considerations...... 58 5.1.2 Enhancing Sustainable Mobility.................... 59 5.1.3 Addressing Environmental Challenges......... 61 5.1.4 Ensuring Community Inclusion..................... 63 5.2 Pilot Neighborhood A- District 10........................ 64 5.3 Pilot Neighborhood B- District 7......................... 74 06 FUTURE WORK................................................. 91 6.1 Transition Experiments................................................... 92 6.2 Scaling Up.............................................................. 94 6.3 The Avoid-Shift-Improve Framework..................... 96 6.4 Conclusion............................................................. 98 07 REFERENCES.................................................... 99 1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 OBJECTIVE OF THE STUDY Aqaba is a growing city with a vibrant culture, a desirable investment climate, and one of Jordan’s vital tourism attractions. As its sole coastal city, Aqaba plays a major role in the development of the country’s economy. Globally, increased rates of urbanization and industrialization have had very significant adverse impacts on climate and society including; CO 2 emissions, traffic casualties, local air quality, social inequity, and loss of street space. In the 21 st century, global pressures that play out at a city scale – such as climate change, economic fluctuations, and disease pandemics − pose new challenges. To overcome these challenges and to accommodate Aqaba’s increasing population and economy, we must look to the future and consider how we can build resilient neighborhoods that reflect the city’s identity and values. In addition to economic development, social and environmental dimensions of sustainability should also be considered in a city that should be known for its high quality of life and remarkable neighborhoods to live in. This study aims to provide a framework for transformational change in Aqaba’s neighborhoods in order to build towards a sustainable, resilient city with an improved environment, inclusive mobility, and increased social equity. 5 1.2 IMPACT OF COVID-19 Due to the ongoing spread of the coronavirus disease, COVID-19, Jordanian officials began implementing unprecedented lockdowns across the Kingdom. Under the measure in Aqaba, individuals were not permitted to enter or exit the city without special permits. All schools, universities, public institutions, and businesses were closed, and only essential local stores were permitted to open when complying with strict health protocols. Citizens were permitted to go out during certain hours of the day, by foot, to meet their basic needs and buy essentials from stores available in their neighborhoods(UNDP, 2020). The impact of COVID-19 and lockdown measures on society, the economy, and infrastructure has been significant. With this new lifestyle came a quick realization of the basic human needs of space, freedom, and nature; all things we quickly recognized were almost overwhelmingly lacking. Movement restrictions also gave us a glimpse of what life could be like in cities and in our neighborhoods without high levels of traffic due to particularly high levels of individual car usage. As a result, air and noise pollution were also reduced; it became much easier for walking and cycling; and people were encouraged to support their local neighborhood stores. It could also be advocated that such trends and travel behaviors observed during the lockdown should be sustained after the pandemic, not just during emergencies. PRE-COVID AIR POLLUTION TRAFFIC DURING LOCKDOWN BETTER AIR QUALITY ACTIVE MODES OF TRAVEL HYPERMARKETS NEIGHBORHOOD STORES 6 1.3 CHARACTERISTICS OF URBAN RESILIENCE RESILIENT CITIES A resilient city is characterized by its capacity to withstand or absorb the impact of a hazard through resistance or adaptation, which enables it to maintain certain basic functions and structures during a crisis and bounce back or recover from an event(UNISDR,2007). The COVID-19 pandemic provides an unprecedented opportunity to understand how cities might be affected by pandemics and what actions are needed to minimize the impacts and enhance urban resiliency. Cities must ensure that their recovery strategies and investment decisions, strengthen, rather than weaken, its resilience. A resilience-based approach can be useful in any planning opportunity but it can be especially useful now that cities need fresh new ideas to help them avoid similar crises. This requires a transformational change in capacities from current stressful situations that challenge and deteriorate urban resilience to new states of higher resilience. Such transformation requires strengthening and connecting all inherent dimensions of urban resilience that consists of people(individual and communities); places(infrastructure and ecosystems); and governance(institutions, partnerships, policies, and laws)(Arup, 2014). 1. People’s Resilience People’s resilience- also known as social resilience- is defined as their ability to self-organize and mobilize their skills and capabilities in order to source new opportunities and generate new forms of innovation, as well as their ability to act in solidarity in the aftermath of a disruption. 2. Places’ Resilience The appearance of cities and their landscape context have a significant impact on their ability to recover and persevere from stresses and shocks. Cities should work towards a sustainable environment which requires conserving natural resources and protecting ecosystems to support the well-being and quality of life in a city. Infrastructure should maintain function over time regardless of the stresses and shocks experienced and should remain adaptive to all social demands of today and the needs of future generations. 3. Governance Resilience In building urban resilience, proactive leadership is paramount. It is also important to anticipate shocks and understand the long-standing vulnerabilities experienced due to urban stresses. Clear sustainabilityoriented goals should be set along with empowerment of citizens to co-design, co-create, and co-produce thus having a shared responsibility and accountability of the present and future of urban resilience. For political action to be backed up, proposed actions require a multi-actor partnership involving public, private, and civil actors. 7 PEOPLE Social inclusion and self-reliance. URBAN RESILIENCE PLACE Robust infrastructures and urban ecosystems. GOVERNANCE Partnership with community and connections with change makers. Dimensions of urban resilience. RESILIENT NEIGHBORHOODS Neighborhoods have a strong physical reality inside cities with distinctive physical, social, and economic characteristics. They are one of the main units that play an important role in the formation of cities and where people live and spend most of their time. Thus, planning and design of resilient neighborhoods as a significant geographic and social unit has a crucial role for creating a resilient city. Resilience is about strengthening our community’s response and adaptation to big changes and deep challenges. We create a stronger, more connected community, where everyone’s basic needs are met- balanced with the planet’s needs. Building a greater sense of connection to the people and places where we live is important as we recognize and celebrate our interdependence and grow“local selfreliance”. Therefore, we define neighborhood resilience as a neighborhood’s ability to adapt and act in proactive ways that ensures the lasting livelihood of a community and its ability to pivot in times of crisis(FES, 2020). 8 CHARACTERISTICS OF RESILIENT NEIGHBORHOODS In this study, we will attempt to provide a framework for transformational change in Aqaba’s neighborhoods that targets 13 characteristics which aim for resilience in these neighborhoods. These characteristics fall under four main categories: Urban Planning, Mobility, Environment, and Community Inclusion. URBAN PLANNING Efficient usage of any developed areas to make them as compact as possible. Integrated variety and mix of parks and community spaces that are accessible and suitable to a range of ages and abilities. Access to opportunities and services within a walkable distance. MOBILITY Well-connected streets and trails that encourage active modes of travel. Reliable high quality public transportation services that are safe and easily accessible by all residents. Minimum environmental impact and low CO 2 emissions from motor vehicles. ENVIRONMENT Conservation of natural areas, existing ecologies, and biodiversity. Efficient energy consumption, renewable energy, and low CO 2 emissions. Sustainable stormwater management. Sustainable waste management practices. COMMUNITY INCLUSION Equal opportunities for all genders. Inclusive services for people with disabilities. Community engagement in planning and decisionmaking processes. 9 2. THE CITY OF AQABA: AN OVERVIEW 2.1 URBAN PLANNING IN AQABA Aqaba has a strategic location at Jordan’s southernmost point, on the Gulf of Aqaba lying at the tip of the Red Sea and at the crossroads of the continents of Asia and Africa. The city had a population of 213,000 in 2020 and a land area of 375 square kilometers, covering a 27 km long sea front(Department of Statistics, 2020). The Aqaba Special Economic Zone(ASEZ) was established in 2001 as a developed investment zone with multiple economic activities that are characterized by customs and reduced consistent tax exemptions within the most important initiatives from the Government of the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan to support the local economy in developmental motivations and increasing the national income (ASEZA, 2001). This area is being administered under a single integrated government entity, the Aqaba Special Economic Zone Authority(ASEZA), which is charged with coordinating the economic and social development of all the diverse activities and resources within the ASEZ as a special free trade economic zone. The initial ASEZ Master Plan was adopted in 2001 and divides Aqaba into five special areas for the promotion of urban, tourist, commercial, academic, and other investment sectors. The areas are Aqaba town, the port areas, the coral coastal zone, the southern industrial zone, and the airport industrial zone(Oxford Business Group, 2018). Residential Civic Tourism Resorts Mixed Use Governmental/Institutional Light Industry Heavy Industry Airport/Seaport/Railroad Services Private Use Recreational/Open Space/Buffer Natural Reserves Historical Development Reserve Public Beach Logistics Canal Gulf of Aqaba ASEZA General Land Use Plan(ASEZA 2001). 11 2.2 MOBILITY IN AQABA Aqaba is characterized by mobility trends that are similar to those of other Jordanian cities. However, it does have its own unique challenges and potential opportunities that set it apart from other cities and towns in the Kingdom. Transportation in the coastal town is dominated by the private car. This is not surprising in a country where car ownership has been increasing at over 6% per year(Jordan Strategy Forum, 2018) and where there has been little investment in public transport or other alternatives. The dominance of the private car has presented a whole host of challenges related to pressures on household expenditures, increasing energy demand and greenhouse gas emissions, economic losses due to traffic congestion, and the lack of equal access to employment and educational opportunities- especially for women. Many of these challenges have been previously highlighted in other FES studies(Attari et al., 2020)(Tarawneh et al., 2020). Aqaba specifically has a unique set of challenges. A recent study completed for the Aqaba Development Corporation found that although Aqaba may not generally suffer from traffic congestion due to high traffic volumes, it does have a number of problematic areas and intersections which present safety risks for drivers and pedestrians. The city’s hot summer climate may also be viewed as a unique challenge as it may limit opportunities for non-motorized travel, at least in certain times of the year(Aqaba Development Corporation, 2016). On the other hand, there are several noteworthy opportunities to highlight in Aqaba’s current mobility system. Unlike the capital Amman, Aqaba has relatively flat terrain and its street network is more grid-like. These features, coupled with the relatively small population and low traffic volumes, place Aqaba in a unique position to invest in alternative, more sustainable modes of transport. Unlike Amman, Aqaba’s mobility system is also more balanced in terms of accommodating various road users. Many sidewalks are continuous; pedestrian crossings are more often respected by drivers; and the city’s road network does not have the bridges, tunnels, and multi-level interchanges that have come to characterize the streets of Amman. Finally, as a prime tourist destination and the only coastal city in Jordan, Aqaba is also well-positioned to invest in public transport and micromobility solutions that are more tourist-friendly and can accommodate the influx of visitors during peak periods. Technologybased solutions such as ride-hailing apps have witnessed tremendous success in Amman. This can be replicated with similar services for bike-sharing or on-demand ride sharing services, for example, in Aqaba. View of King Hussein Street(Corniche Street), Aqaba. 12 2.3 ENVIRONMENT IN AQABA The City of Aqaba is strategically important to Jordan as it is the country’s only seaport city and an important import/export hub. In recent years, Aqaba has become a touristic destination well known for its diving and beach resort. Additionally, the city houses several industrial activities including being the medium for Jordan’s phosphate exports and the main administrative center within the south of Jordan. Aqaba is vulnerable to earthquakes, flash floods, sandstorms and industrial hazards. The northern parts of Aqaba are the most vulnerable regions for flash flood hazards. These areas contain the town’s residential expansion area, the Aqaba International Industrial Estate, the King Hussein International Airport, and the Northern light industries and logistics areas. Aqaba is also facing various environmental challenges resulting from decades of non-sustainable production and consumption patterns. In addition to the increase in produced waste quantities, Aqaba has been losing biodiversity, gaining air and water pollution, and suffering from land degradation which has led to an increase in pressure over local ecological systems. GROUNDWATER The long periods of daily sunshine, high temperatures year round, and little vegetation cover enhances the process of actual evaporation which makes direct recharge of groundwater rare. On the other hand; high infiltration rates; low soil field capacities; coarse textures (classified mainly as sands); the revealed weakness of structural zones as lineaments; active faults; and the shallow groundwater table allow good parts of precipitation to percolate down to the groundwater body, forming recharge. CLIMATE The wind is mostly directed from north to northwest and from south to southwest. Dust and sandy winds are rare with average wind speed ranging from 11.5 to 23 miles per hour which has a noticable role in dropping the humidity. South winds are also fairly rare. Since the city crosses the hyper-arid area of Wadi Araba, it is very dry. While the relative humidity is high in winter time, it decreases during the hot summer months usually being between 28-30%. The sunlight is intense especially in the summer months with the highest sunshine hours registered in May, June, and July and the lowest in December, January, and February(Odat et al., 2018). ECOLOGY Despite the harsh environment, Aqaba hosts a unique ecosystem of rare plants and herbs. Some of the native plants include ziziphus spina-cristi, phoenix dactuylifera, hyphaene thebaica, and acacia tortilis which are known to be drought resistant. Most native plants are not widely used and not available commercially, nevertheless several other species have been modified and adapted to the Aqaba climate. These include various cacti and succulents; groundcovers and climbers; shrubs and grasses; and trees and palms which are all used in landscaping. The Gulf of Aqaba is home to some of the finest marine life in the Middle East, while its coral reefs rival those found elsewhere in the world. The gulf is very narrow- at its northern end it is only five kilometers wide- and quite deep, ranging in depth from 1,000 to 1,800 meters. The depth of the gulf, combined with its isolation from sea currents, minimize turbulence and improve visibility. 13 SOLID WASTE Aqaba generates around 150 tons of solid waste daily which consists of organic waste, paper, plastic, metals, and others, as indicated in the figure below(EDAMA, 2018). It is also worth mentioning that no separation is done and all waste is disposed in the same mechanism. Municipal cleaning is done in partnership with the private sector through contract, with ASEZA as the contracting authority. Municipal Solid Waste(MSW) collection coverage is estimated at about 90%; about 50% of MSW is food waste and 35% is packaging waste that would be potentially be available for recovery. Most MSW ends up at dump sites and landfills, whereas only 7% is currently recovered informally in the city(UNDP, 2015). Regulatory measures regarding plastics- and more specifically, plastic bags- are being introduced in Aqaba, where tourism is an important economic pillar disadvantaged by visible garbage and pollution to the sea and surrounding coral. However, the ASEZA intends to change the existing pattern of plastic bag consumption and disposal. It has Migrating birds at the Aqaba Bird Observatory. developed a preventive waste and plastic bag management plan for the city entitled Aqaba Preventive Solid Waste Management or APreWaM. This management plan is based on the assessment of the current On Aqaba’s shorelines, one can find species such as the ghost crab, situation and sets out appropriate actions in order to reduce plastic bag sandhoppers, and the mole crab. The sea waters, meanwhile, host consumption overall. a plethora of marine life including starfish, sea cucumbers, crabs, shrimps, sea urchins, many species of fish and several worms which burrow into the sandy sea bottom. 1% 1% Biowaste A variety of sea grasses can be found in more shallow waters, providing both food and shelter to the fish which inhabit the area. Several species of eel make their home in the gulf’s grass beds, where one can also find seahorses and pipe fish(Department of Environment; 1% 1% 4% 4% 10% UNDP, 2015). 4% 4% 50% In addition, Aqaba is identified as an important bird area. The man15% made pools within many of the new developments throughout the city 10% attract significant numbers of waders, ducks, and other birds on their Paper& Cardboard Plastic Others Biowas M te etal Paper& Gla C ss ardboard Plastic Cloth Others Wood and yard waste Metal annual migration. Raptor migration alone involves at least 100,000 birds per season(UNDP, 2015). 15% 15% 50% Glass Cloth Wood and yard waste Composition of waste in Aqaba. Source: Ministry of Local Administration 14 15% FLASH FLOODS Aqaba region is best described in term of its climate as arid; while maximum annual precipitation values do not exceed 50 mm in the best conditions and are restricted to the winter season. The potential pan evaporation is estimated 4100 mm/year,(MWI, 1995). These factors give the area the dryness character, and the soil its salinization. With that, thunderstorms can sweep the area in winter to create run off and then rapid surface flash floods. These are the responsible factors for the occurrence of recent wadi shapes within the deposits along the coastal area. The figure below represents the size of the vast catchment area funneling to the gulf of Aqaba.The large size of the catchment area combined with high and short intensity of rainfall, presents high potential for sudden runoff. This phenomenon is exacerbated by the steep nature of the catchment area, which increases runoff speed. Floods are also affected by the roughness of the terrains they cross. Many developments in Aqaba City are taking place on alluvial fans of wadis. Although these areas remain moderately dry, they are extremely vulnerable to disasters when a flash flood occurs, especially in the northern parts of the city. Authorities in Aqaba are taking measures to mitigate damage caused by the rainy season, such as regulatory dams, drainage and sewage infrastructure, and early flood warning systems. Lower Yutum Upper Yutum Gulf of Aqaba Coastal Wadis Wadi Titin Catchment Hydrology Hydrology map of the valleys surrounding Aqaba(Farhan and Anaba, 2016). AIR QUALITY Air pollution has been an increasing concern in Aqaba. The city is surrounded by many air pollution sources such as activities using fertilizers, electricity generation, waste water treatment, and crude oil activities. It is worth mentioning that heavy transportation activities such as the use of diesel vehicles may also cause negative effects on the city. Aqaba is surrounded by high mountains which block the diffusion of pollutants generated in the city. The climate of the city is hyper-arid with a low atmospheric moisture regime which gives a unique characterization to pollution caused by chemical reactions with the gaseous constitution of the atmosphere. Seven air pollutants(O 3 , CO, H 2 S, NH 3 , NO X , PM 10 , SO 2 ) were observed over Aqaba at three monitoring stations distributed throughout the city. The diurnal variation of NO X (NO+ NO 2 ) concentration presents a peak during the early morning/evening hours while high levels of NH 3 , SO 2 , H 2 S, and PM 10 are present at the southern and port areas of the city due to industrial activities. The diurnal variation of CO, NO X , and PM 10 concentration also peak during the early morning/evening hours. These peak concentrations are linked to traffic intensity. The high levels of gaseous pollutants(SO 2 , NH 3 , H 2 S, PM 10 , and NO X ) which is recorded within Aqaba on hourly and daily averages, exceeds the limits specified in JS1140/2006(Odat et al., 2018). The degree of severity of pollution episodes are highly dependent on wind direction; where southerly winds carry local transportation pollution(i.e., ship, trucks, etc.) and possibly some industrial emissions towards the north end of the Red Sea; northerly winds are associated with the transport of regional O 3 . Under the prevailing northerly wind flows(90% of the time), the quality of air is relatively good for all primary pollutants except for O 3 , which was elevated. This is indicative of downwind regional transport of this secondary pollutant from the Mediterranean coast. However, during days with southerly air flow, air quality was significantly deteriorated with elevated levels of sulfur dioxide(SO 2 ) and nitrogen oxides(NO X ). 15 RESPONSE TO CLIMATE CHANGE ENERGY CONSUMPTION 00 2 0 4 0 ASEZA has adopted a number of policies associated with the control, management, and protection of the natural environment. The environmental policy requires preservation and protection of the environment and the sustained development of the Zone’s natural resources. Moreover, the energy conservation policy promotes the provision of adequate energy to consumers at the least possible cost while attempting to achieve sustainable development of the energy sector and meeting the needs of socioeconomic development in the ASEZ. ASEZA has also committed to a 14% reduction of the municipality’s greenhouse gas(GHG) emissions as well as an adaptation of climate change in line with national commitments for 2030. The involvement of all citizens and stakeholders of the municipality is considered crucial for achieving set targets and are considered the most important resource for the city, especially regarding its GHG saving targets. The overall reduction target of the ASEZ region is 85,122.87 tn of CO 2 , up to 2030 compared with the Business As Usual scenario. This amount regards the 14% reduction target according to the Intended Nationally Determined Contribution supported by GIZ(CES-MED, 2012). Total CO2 emissions(kton) Respective total emissions for the baseline year- including emissions from waste management- equal 339,676 tn of CO 2 and are presented in M th u e n f i o c l i l p o a w l i B n u g il c d h in a g rt s ; Tertiary(non municipal) Buildings 120 The energy balance for ASEZA, or its Baseline Emissions Inventory, has been developed in line with the Covenant of Mayors for Climate and Energy Reporting Guidelines and utilizing the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change emission factor approach for all compulsory sectors and one optional sector, namely: • • Municipal Buildings, Equipment and Facilities; • • Municipal Public Lighting; • • Residential Buildings; • • Tertiary Buildings, Equipment and Facilities; • • Transport(Municipal/Public/Private); • • Solid Waste Management. The highest energy consumer is the Tertiary sector, followed by the Private Transport and Residential sectors while the Municipal sector’s consumption is the lowest. The Authority, including the Municipal Buildings, Public Lighting, and Municipal fleet consumes 36,887 MWh of energy, with this consumption having almost equally balanced its contribution. Regarding total energy consumption, all sectors in the ASEZ consume 740,292 MWh with each sector’s contribution presented in the following pie chart- noting ASEZA’s share includes Municipal Buildings, Public Lighting, and Municipal fleet(CES-MED, 2012); 60 140 6 0 00 8 0 2 0 100 Residential Buildings Total CO2 emissions(kton) Public Lighting 5% 140 120 100 8 0 4 0 MunicipMaul nFilceieptal Buildings TertiarPyu(bnolicn Tmraunnsipciopratl) Buildings Private& Commercial RTerasnidsepnotrital Buildings Waste ManagmPeunbtlic Lighting Municipal Fleet Public Transport Private& Commercial Transport Solar thermal Landfill gas Kerosene Gasoline Diesel 27% 5% 27% 32% 32% 10% 26% Private& Commercial transport Public transport Residential buildings Tertiary(non municipal buildings) Pri A v S a E t Z e A & Commercial transport Public transport Residential buildings Tertiary(non municipal buildings) Waste Managment Heating dieSsoellar thermal Landfill gas 10% ASEZA Total CO 2 emissions per sector and per fuel source(CES-MED, 2012). Kerosene Gasoline Energy consumption allocation per sector(CES-MED, 2012). 26% Diesel 16 Heating diesel 2.4 COMMUNITY INCLUSION IN AQABA Creating cohesive cities involves both social and physical aspects. Reinforcing local identity and culture fosters strong interpersonal relationships while strengthening their collective power to enhance the environment in which they live, work, create, and play. These relationships are sustained by several practices including; social networks and community organizations; artistic expression; and the preservation of cultural heritage, including religion, language, and traditions. Ideally, these practices are reinforced by spatial interventions that shape the places where communities develop and connect. Provision of communal facilities, public spaces, and physical accessibility can help to strengthen community cohesion and avoid isolation. Despite progress in certain areas much of Aqaba’s infrastructure is not designed in an inclusive way; creating unnecessary barriers for a lot of its citizens, especially females and people with disabilities. Female labor force participation in Jordan remains low at 14 per cent, compared to 54 per cent for males, according to 2019 figures issued by the Department of Statistics(DoS)(DoS, 2019). A 2018 DoS report estimated the gender pay gap in the public sector at 18 per cent and in the private sector at 14.1 per cent(DoS, 2018). The national estimate of unemployment for Jordanian women in the third quarter of 2020 was 33.6 per cent, compared to 21.2 per cent for men(DoS, 2020). Infrastructure, if designed and implemented correctly, can also empower people to be part of societal and economic development. Aqaba has a great opportunity to strengthen its community cohesion through its neighborhood committees that were created and configured by the Neighborhoods Development Department in ASEZA. The Department aims at increasing the participation of citizens in decision-making regarding their needs and working with them as partners to meet these needs; as well as building their abilities and skills in order to benefit from the growing opportunities in the ASEZ and to work with them as effective partners to improve their economic, social, and cultural reality(ASEZA, 2021). Community inclusion workshop, August 2021. 17 3. APPROACH& METHODOLOGY 3.1 TRANSITION MANAGEMENT WHAT IS TRANSITION MANAGEMENT IN AN URBAN CONTEXT? Transition Management is an approach designed to enable, facilitate, and guide the social, technical, and political transformations toward sustainability. In its application in an urban context, the Transition Management approach provides a framework to bring together multiple stakeholders with different perspectives and approaches in a‘Transition Arena’ - which in this project is residential neighborhoods in Aqaba. All stakeholders involved are encouraged to structure their shared challenges with the current system and develop a shared vision and goals towards sustainable solutions(DRIFT, 2014). Implementing a Transition Management approach has the prospect of resulting in three key outcomes: A sense of direction Proposing a strategic future perspective which addresses the fundamental changes needed to reach a sustainable future. An impulse for local change Inspiring new and enhancing existing initiatives that contribute to the envisioned future. Collective empowerment Enabling actors in the city to tackle challenges and seize opportunities for a sustainable city. 1. Setting the scene 2. Exploring local dynamics 3. Framing the transition challenge 4. Envisioning a sustainable city 5. Reconnecting long- and short-term 6. Engaging and anchoring 7. Getting into action Methodological steps involved in the Transition Management approach. 19 3.2 METHODOLOGY 01 02 03 04 01 02 03 04 Setting the scene A transition team is formed to drive the process and embed it in the local context. Exploring local dynamics The transition team starts to explore the city’s dynamics; conducting meetings, doing research, and working towards analyzing the current situation. Framing the transition challenge The team identify challenges and create a shared problem framing. Envisioning a sustainable city Subsequently, they exchange and elaborate perspectives on a possible future, thereby creating visionary images for the future of the city. 05 06 07 05 06 07 T EXT EX Reconnecting long- and short-term As a final step in the transition setting, change agents elaborate transition pathways indicating fundamental changes and corresponding actions needed to reach the envisioned future. Engaging and anchoring Actions are undertaken to make the transition study public and give others a chance to adopt and adapt it and relate it to their own agenda and practices. Getting into action Transition experiments, in line with the transition pathway, are initiated or adapted. More actors become engaged. Insights from these experiments can be taken to a more strategic level. 20 3.3 IMPLEMENTING TRANSITION MANAGEMENT 1. Setting the scene for Transition Management Our Transition Management team consists of a climate and energy expert, an environmental and sustainability consultant, a transportation planning and policy consultant, urban planning consultants, an architect, project manager, and researcher who work in cooperation with ASEZA’s Directorate of Studies and Planning, Environment Directorate, Neighborhoods Development Department, Directorate of Public Works, and City Commissioner. 2. Exploring local dynamics The first few months of the Transition Management process in Aqaba were dedicated to conducting meetings with ASEZA’s officials, the selection of pilot neighborhoods, site visits, data collection, and analysis - taking into account an assessment of environmental, planning, mobility, and social aspects. See analysis in Chapter 4. 3. Framing the challenges The analysis resulted in identifying issues and challenges in infrastructure, services, traveling behaviors, and their environmental impact. A dedicated workshop was conducted to engage the community in identifying their challenges and needs in regards to planning, the environment, and mobility in the neighborhoods; along with involving them in providing recommendations and proposals that address their challenges with the aim of reaching sustainable and resilient neighborhoods. See challenges and workshop outcomes in Chapter 4. 4. Envisioning a resilient city The Transition Management team agreed on four guiding principles that would allow the city to be resilient through its neighborhoods: 1- Aqaba as a well-designed and an attractive city to visit and live in; 2- Aqaba as an accessible city that encourages active modes of travel; 3- Aqaba as an energy efficient and eco-friendly city; and 4- Aqaba as a socially cohesive city. For each guiding principle, designs and recommendations were created from a combination of experiences and ideas of the project team, which together embody a vision that describes the features of sustainable, resilient neighborhoods. See recommendations in Chapter 5. 5. Reconnecting long- and short-term To bridge the gap between the vision of the future and the present, the team engaged in several meetings to develop a pathway that includes goals and action ideas for the short-, mid-, and long-term. In addition, the team came together with recommendations and considerations for the city to scale. See Chapter 6. 6. Engaging and anchoring Once the transition study is consolidated, it will be time to engage with a wider audience. The transition study provides a starting point for a wider group of people, organizations, and initiatives to adopt ambitions for a sustainable future and relate this to their own agendas and practices. A first step in this direction could be a kick-off event, where the team would present the transition pathway to all stakeholders involved. The goal is to have a lasting impact, though this does not automatically imply that the transition team has to stay intact or that its meetings need to continue. Activities are undertaken to strengthen initiatives that contribute to the visualized goals and to challenge actors to play their part in the transition dynamics. ASEZA and other organizations may put the agenda into practice or adopt and adapt it. 7. Getting into action Transition experiments are short-term actions through which alternative structures, cultures, and practices are explored to catalyze long-term change and encourage community participation. The activities, when successful, serve to demonstrate that the envisioned future is attainable. The transition study provides direction for the long-term and inspires actions for the short-term. As a follow-up to the study, some of the proposed transition experiments can be elaborated and realized by ASEZA and newly involved actors. Also, other ongoing, planned, and newly emerging activities can be linked to the study thus reinforcing these activities by making them more sustainable and resilient. 21 3.4 FOCUSING ON NEIGHBORHOODS Neighborhoods are an integral part of cities. Thus, the resilience of a city can be measured through the resilience of its neighborhoods. The clear district divisions in Aqaba’s Master Plan allow for a more focused look into each district when studying the resilience of Aqaba’s neighborhoods. In order to maximize the impact of this study, it is more effective to narrow down the scale of work into a defined set of neighborhoods. Selected neighborhoods can turn into pilot case studies that set an example for strategies that can be easily replicated accross similar areas. The selection process for the study neighborhoods focuses on the importance of covering Aqaba’s diversity in terms of demographics, socioeconomic status, density, etc., so as to be able to come up with a set of solutions that can be implemented in the majority of Aqaba’s neighborhoods based on each of their unique characteristics. The five neighborhoods that were initially considered included: • • District 5 Neighborhood • • District 7 Neighborhood • • District 10 Neighborhood • • Al-Shalaleh Neighborhood • • King Hussein Street(Corniche Street) District 10 District 7 District 5 King Hussein Street Al-Shalaleh Neighborhood Neighborhoods of Aqaba. 22 3.4.1 FOCUS NEIGHBORHOODS SELECTION CRITERIA After meeting with the City Commissioner at ASEZA, the target areas for comprehensive analysis were narrowed down to two neighborhoods with a 300-600m radius. The focus neighborhoods selected are: • • The western area of the District 10 neighborhood • • The District 7 neighborhood The selection of the two neighborhoods was based on the following criteria: Replicability The selected neighborhoods include a set of typical conditions that are mirrored accross a large number of neighborhoods in Aqaba, such as street typologies, peripheral green areas and buffer zones, services, etc. This allows for the study to have a larger impact by replicating the outcomes across the largest area possible, rather than cater for highly specific or unique conditions. Potential for Implementation Both of the selected neighborhoods include(or are adjacent to) urban upgrading projects that are currently on ASEZA’s desktop. This presents an opportunity to accelerate the incorporation of the study outcomes within the conceptual development of these projects. Socioeconomic Diversity It is crucial to include neighborhoods with high socioeconomic diversity. They should not be exclusive to one social class, race, or ethnic background. This allows the analysis to be inclusive and address the needs of the greater majority rather than a selected few. Accessibility and Services Availability The selected neighborhoods take into consideration the availability of services within the set boundaries. It is important for the study that these neighborhoods are not on either extremities of containing an abundance of services that are easily accessible or areas that are isolated and lack any kind of service. Therefore, moderate availability of both elements is key. General Land Use Studying neighborhoods that mainly include residential zones. Western area of the District 10 neighborhood. District 7 neighborhood. 23 4. ANALYZING SELECTED NEIGHBORHOODS 4.1 SELECTED NEIGHBORHOODS ANALYSIS CRITERIA URBAN PLANNING Vacancy| Solid and Void Level of density within the residential area and the availability of open spaces or parks. Existing Land Use The distribution of land and services within the neighborhood where focus is on the level of privacy for inhabitants and the amount of undesirable car traffic within dense residential areas. Access to Services Essential public services and proper infrastructure insuring residents’ access to all essential services resulting in an improved quality of life. Such services mainly include infrastructure networks and public facilities (mosques, schools, health centers, shops, etc.). MOBILITY Road and Pedestrian Networks Analysis of road hierarchy as well as road accesses to all land plots within a neighborhood. In addition, analysis of pedestrian networks. Accessibility Ease of accessibility for residents to services and green open spaces, either using vehicles or on foot and the level of safety and security of pedestrians accessing these services. Public Transportation Networks Tracing public transportation routes and designated stops within the neighborhood. ENVIRONMENT Topography Effect on walkability and natural storm water drainage patterns. Site Greenery The availability of open public spaces and public sports fields with safe pedestrian access. Waste Sorting Study of waste sorting systems within neighborhoods. Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy(EE/RE) Energy efficiency measures within buildings and neighborhoods as well as utilization of renewable energy. Sustainable Water and Stormwater Management Water saving practices and use of water saving devices within buildings and neighborhoods examining the possibility of rainwater management through utilization of permeable surfaces as well as rain water harvesting and reuse for gardening/ landscaping. COMMUNITY INCLUSION Accessibility for Persons with Disabilities It is important to assess whether existing mobility networks and infrastructure accommodate persons with disabilities including wheelchair accessible ramps and aid for the visually impaired. Outcomes of Participatory Community Workshops Workshops involving a diverse array of community stakeholders are a great tool to get insight on the community’s needs, priorities, and challenges. 25 4.2 PILOT NEIGHBORHOOD A- DISTRICT 10 OVERVIEW| 3D District Study Area Population 10 478,908 m 2 Approx. 14,900 District 10 is split into two areas- those east and west of Prince Hasan Street. The study focuses on the western area and its connection to surrounding services and green areas, capturing a catchment radius of approximately 600m. The Al-Farouq Highway creates the neighborhood’s western and northern borders with Ayla to the west and vacant land to the north. AlKuwait Street borders the neighborhood’s southern edge. AL FAROUK ST l-Farouk St. A Prince Has an St. ait St. Kuw AL FAROUK ST AL QUDS ST SITE LOCATION AIRPO RT ST REET 26 DISTRICT 10 - ANALYSIS OF CURRENT SITUATION VACANCY| SOLID AND VOID Al-Farouk St. BUILDING HEIGHT Al-Farouk St. Prince Hasan st. Prince Hasan st. Kuwait St. 0 20 60 140 300m Solid and Void Vacancy represents the building density level within the cluster, where the dark gray hatched shapes represent the plots with constructed buildings while the white voids represent the empty plots. This figure shows that most of the residential plots are constructed forming around 80% of the total residential plots. Three Floors Two Floors Kuwait St. 0 20 60 140 300m 27 DISTRICT 10 - ANALYSIS OF CURRENT SITUATION EXISTING LAND USE Al-Farouk St. EXISTING SERVICES WITHIN CATCHMENT RADIUS Al-Farouk St. Prince Hasan st. Prince Hasan st. 100m Kuwait St. 0 20 60 140 300m Total Number of Plots 621 Residential Public Services Educational Commercial Mosque Green Area The planned residential area forms around 54% of the total area with an allowance of three floor buildings according to the regulations. The area has a full capacity of approximately 3,654 apartments and 14,900 inhabitants. In addition, the area has schools, a mosque, a commercial block on Prince Hasan Street and planned green areas that are currently not utilized. Kuwait St. 0 20 60 140 300m Educational Mosque Hypermarket/ Neighborhood Stores Pharmacy 28 DISTRICT 10 - ANALYSIS OF CURRENT SITUATION ENTRANCES Al-Farouk St. ROAD HIERARCHY Al-Farouk St. Prince Hasan st. Prince Hasan St. Kuwait St. 0 20 60 140 300m The neighborhood has 6 entrance/exit points leading to a main internal ring road that loops within the neighborhood. The majority of neighborhood entrances are located on surrounding collector roads(two on Prince Hasan Street and two on Kuwait Street), while two entrances connect to the Al-Farouk Highway. Kuwait St. Arterial Road 40m Collector Road 30m Main Neighborhood Road 20m Local Road 14m Local Road 12m 0 20 60 140 300m 29 DISTRICT 10 - ANALYSIS OF CURRENT SITUATION TRAFFIC DIRECTION Al-Farouk St. PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION Al-Farouk St. Prince Hasan St. Prince Hasan St. Kuwait St. 0 20 60 140 300m Two-way Traffic Traffic Light at Intersection All streets within the study area include two-way traffic directions, regardless of street width. There is only one traffic light within the study area, located at the intersection of Prince Hasan Street and Kuwait Street. Kuwait St. Bus Route Bus Stop 0 20 60 140 300m 30 DISTRICT 10 - ANALYSIS OF CURRENT SITUATION PEDESTRIAN NETWORK Al-Farouk St. PARKING Al-Farouk St. Prince Hasan St. Prince Hasan St. Kuwait St. 0 20 60 140 300m Pedestrian Crossing Pedestrian Footpath Sidewalk Zebra crossings are provided at all neighborhood entrances, however, they are mostly missing from internal neighbohood intersections. Sidewalks are missing at vacant plots. Though infrastructure elements for pedestrian mobility exist in numerous locations, they do not form a continuous network and are hardly ever accessible to people with disabilities. Kuwait St. 0 20 60 140 300m On-street/Curb-side Parking Cul de Sac Parking Designated/ Recessed Parking On-street, curb-side parking was observed on all neighborhood roads. However, designated parking areas are located near commercial and service plots and residential cul de sacs. 31 +32.00 +34.00 +36.00 +38.00 +40.00 +42.00 +44.00 +46.00 +48.00 DISTRICT 10 - ANALYSIS OF CURRENT SITUATION WASTE DISPOSAL Al-Farouk St. TOPOGRAPHY Al-Farouk St. Wadi Al-Haswah Prince Hasan St. Prince Hasan St. Kuwait St. 0 20 60 140 300m Dumpster Litter Bin Dumpsters and litter bins in the area are not sorted by material. No measures for recycling waste were observed. Kuwait St. 0 20 60 140 300m Contour Interval= 2m The site’s topography is relatively perceived as flat with an average slope of 1.6%. The ground level descends from a maximum altitude of 48m in the east to 32m in the west. The natural stormwater drainage path is along Wadi Al-Haswah, as shown on the map. 32 DISTRICT 10 - ANALYSIS OF CURRENT SITUATION VEGETATION AND GREEN AREAS Al-Farouk St. A linear buffer zone with native plants separates the neighborhood from the Al-Farouk Highway on the northern and northwestern side. In addition, plans are currently in the works for a linear park across the northern edge of the Al-Farouk Highway. Land use plans show planned green areas at the center of the neighborhood and within the market block on Prince Hasan Street. However, the first plot is currently undeveloped while the second is used for vehicle parking. Prince Hasan st. Kuwait St. 0 20 60 140 300m Green Areas- according to land use plan, currently unutilized Buffer Zones Planned Linear Park by ASEZA 33 DISTRICT 10 - PHOTO DOCUMENTATION VEGETATION Street trees and shrubs adhering to Aqaba’s guidelines and landsape palette for highway approaches are observed on main roads surrounding the neighborhood including Farouk Street and Kuwait Street(refer to map on previous page). These trees include street shading trees such as ponciana and jacaranda species and date palm trees on medians. Shrubs and vines include pennisetum, lantana camara, and bougainvillea vines planted along fences on both sides of Al-Farouk Street. Wild and native plant species are observed within buffer zones. However, as shown in the map on the previous page, sidewalk plantation within the neighborhood itself becomes much less consistent, less dense, and more random as plants are selected by the residents of each plot. For this reason, most sidewalks within the neighborhood lack any amount of shade for the majority of the day in addition to the use of plant species that hinder pedestrian movement. SHRUBS AND VINES STREET TREES NATIVE TREES AND SHRUBS WITHIN BUFFER ZONES 34 DISTRICT 10 - PHOTO DOCUMENTATION STREETS 40m Street(Al-Farouk Street) 30m Street(Prince Hasan Street) 40m Street(Al-Farouk Street) 30m Street(Kuwait Street) 20m Street(Neighborhood Loop) 12-14 local street adjacent to buffer zone 35 DISTRICT 10 - PHOTO DOCUMENTATION OPEN SPACES Gatherings were observed on the service road opposite from the commercial block on Prince Hasan Street. Residents would purchase snacks and gather in the evening at that location due to a lack of public open spaces. The planned green area shown on land use plans within the commercial block is completely used for parking in reality. Buffer zones contain native plant species but lack any kind of public space amenities. OBSERVED BEHAVIOR ON PRINCE HASAN STREET 5 6 7 12 3 8 4 Gatherings on service road. 1 Gatherings on service road. VACANT LANDS AND GREEN BUFFER ZONES 2 Pop-up retailers. 3 4 District 10 commercial block parking. 5 6 7 8 Buffer zone adjacent to Farouk Street. Cul-de-sac adjacent to buffer zone. Pedestrian path within vacant land. Pedestrian shortcut path within vacant land. 36 DISTRICT 10 - PHOTO DOCUMENTATION ACCESSIBILITY FOR PEDESTRIANS AND BICYCLISTS Several forms of obstacles for pedestrian movement were observed. These include improper placement of sidewalk planters, wrong choice of trees, parked cars, and placement of furniture on sidewalks. Pedestrian footpaths are often inaccessible to persons due to lack of proper access ramps and no amenities for bicyclists were observed. In addition, the vast majority of sidewalks and pedestrian footpaths use impermeable surface materials such as concrete tiles. OBSTRUCTIONS TO PEDESTRIAN MOVEMENT 11 16 10 13 9 8 18 14 17 15 12 9 Sidewalk furniture placement. Parking within sidewalks. PEDESTRIAN FOOTPATHS 10 11 12 13 Planter taking over sidewalk. Planters at center of sidewalk. Planters obstructing continuity. Pedestrian footpath. 14 Entrance to footpath. 15 Entrance to footpath. 16 Entrance to footpath. 17 18 Lack of designated bicycle parking. 37 4.3 PILOT NEIGHBORHOOD B- DISTRICT 7 OVERVIEW| 3D District Study Area Population 7 350,463 m 2 Approx. 6,550 District 7 is a residential cluster bordered by Al-Abdaleyah and Al-Herafeyah Districts to the southeast; Hay AlAaamal Al-Jadeedah to the northeast; District 8, Al-Zahraa, and Al-Faihaa to the north; and District 9 to the west. The residential cluster has a triangular shape- the western side of the triangle (Basman Street) forms the longest edge with 1147m length and 752m on the northeastern side(Jordan Valley Highway), and 784m from the southeastern side (Sharif Al-Hussein Bin Ali Street). AL FAROOQ ST Jordan Valley Highway Basman S t. Al-Sharif Hussein Bin Ali St. AL FAROOQ ST BASMAN STREET AL QUDS ST SITE LOCATION AIRPO RT ST REET STREET ALI BIN SEIN US L-H A 38 DISTRICT 7 - ANALYSIS OF CURRENT SITUATION VACANCY| SOLID& VOID BUILDING HEIGHT 0 20 60 140 300m Solid and Void Vacancy represents the building density level within the neighborhood; where the dark hatched shapes represent the plots with constructed buildings while the white voids represent empty plots. This figure shows that most of the residential plots are constructed forming around 75% of the total residential plots. 0 20 60 140 300m One Floor Buildings Two Floor Buildings Three Floor Buildings Four Floor Buildings The heights of the buildings in the neighborhood range from one floor to four floors. The dominant characteristic of building height in the study area is three floors, according to ASEZA regulations. But some distributed buildings on the western side of the district are four-floor buildings. 10% 14% 46% 30% 39 DISTRICT 7 - ANALYSIS OF CURRENT SITUATION EXISTING LAND USE Total Number of Residential Plots 208 The residential planned area forms around 48% of the total area with an allowance of three floor buildings, according to the regulations. The area has a full capacity of approximately 1,260 apartments and 6,550 inhabitants. In addition, the area has schools, a mosque, a commercial area, and green areas as shown. 15% 8% 4% 1% 24% 48% Residential Educational Mosques Streets Green Areas Stormwater Infrastructure /Owned by ASEZA 40 DISTRICT 7 - ANALYSIS OF CURRENT SITUATION EXISTING SERVICES NEIGHBORHOOD CATCHMENT RADIUS The study area has a variety of services including a kindergarten, two secondary schools, a mosque, two public parking areas, and a commercial complex in the center of the district that contains a pharmacy, supermarket, restaurant, men’s barbershop, vegetable shop, etc. Although the location of the services is off-center toward the northen part of the neighborhood, the maximum walking distance to reach the services is around 500 m - which is acceptable. Educational Mosque Parking Pharmacy Bookstore Falafel Restaurant Men’s Barbershop(Salon) Supermarket Fruit and Vegetable Shop Shisha Shop 100 m 41 DISTRICT 7 - ANALYSIS OF CURRENT SITUATION ENTRANCES ROAD HIERARCHY 0 20 60 140 300m Existing Entrances As shown in the map above, the neighborhood has only two entrances located on Basman Street(western side), an issue which was highlighted by residents during the community workshop. Arterial Road 35m- 45m Collector Road 20m Local Road 12m Pedestrian Pathway 4m 0 20 60 140 300m 42 DISTRICT 7 - ANALYSIS OF CURRENT SITUATION STREET DIRECTION PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION 0 20 60 140 300m All streets in the study area have two-way direction despite the street section and width. In order to provide a proper pedestrian network and bicycle lanes, the street movement directions will be revisited as shown in the next chapter. 0 20 60 140 300m Bus Route Bus Stop Public transportation lines pass by the main roads around the area. There are 5 bus stops on Basman Street. 43 DISTRICT 7 - ANALYSIS OF CURRENT SITUATION PEDESTRIAN NETWORK PARKING 0 20 60 140 300m Sidewalk Pedestrian Footpath The pedestrian network is formed by the sidewalks in front of constructed plots only, a minimal number of pedestrian pathways, and without crossing areas. This leads to disconnected and insufficient pedestrian movement. In addition, pedestrian paths need rehabilitation due to tiling problems, lack of lighting, and a lot of obstacles(such as electrical poles, plants, etc.) in front of pathways. 0 20 60 140 300m There are 4 parking lots in the neighborhood as shown on the map above. The total parking area is 2,000 m 2 . 44 DISTRICT 7 - ANALYSIS OF CURRENT SITUATION TOPOGRAPHY VEGETATION AND GREEN AREAS 0 20 60 140 300m 0 20 60 140 300m The morphology of the site is characterized by a gentle topography with an average slope of 5.5% in which elevations descend from the southeast with an altitude of 108m above sea level to the lowest altitude of 72m above sea level at the northern edge. The percentage of green spaces in the district constitutes 8% of the total area. The green areas contain walkways(linear parks) on the northeastern and western borders in addition to empty land on the southwestern corner which is supposed to be a small park. Most of the street sidewalks in the district are planted with trees, hence, not all trees allow pedestrians to use the sidewalks due to their location. 45 DISTRICT 7 - PHOTO DOCUMENTATION VEGETATION The plantation within the area doesn’t have any theme or a particular plant palette. Sometimes the used plants hinder pedestrian movement on the sidewalk due to their location. 46 DISTRICT 7 - PHOTO DOCUMENTATION SIDEWALK The sidewalks in the study area range in width from 0.8m to 5.5m, taking into consideration that the unconstructed plots don’t have sidewalks. 47 DISTRICT 7 - PHOTO DOCUMENTATION STREETS Most of the streets in the study area are in fairly good condition although some streets have problems such as potholes and surface irregularity. 48 DISTRICT 7 - PHOTO DOCUMENTATION SERVICES The neighborhood’s central services include commercial activities across the street from a mosque. Adjacent to the mosque is a large parking lot. 49 4.4 COMMUNITY INCLUSION WORKSHOP OBJECTIVE A workshop was held in August 2021 to involve residents and stakeholders in identifying the main challenges facing their neighborhoods from their perspective. PARTICIPANTS SELECTION CRITERIA The participants were selected from both focus neighborhoods in an inclusive manner based on the following criteria: • • Equal representation of all genders; • • Including participants from various age groups; • • Employment status; including employed, unemployed, stay-at-home mothers and retired individuals; • • Including persons with disabilities. WORKSHOP PROCEEDINGS Several tools were utilized to engage the participants in identifying the challenges they face within their neighborhoods under specifically addressed topics. Interactive polls Participants were asked a series of questions related to planning, mobility, environment and effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on their daily lives. The poll results were displayed in real-time to trigger discussions and interactions. Categorizing challenges Four boards were dedicated to list general challenges under each different topic. Mapping common daily routes and challenges Each participant was handed a map of their neighborhood to indicate their most commonly used routes(whether on foot, by car, or by bicycle). In addition, participants identified specific locations with obstacles or challenges on the map. 50 ANSWERS TO MOBILITY RELATED POLL QUESTIONS 13% 4% 25% 58% DO YOU WALK WITHIN YOUR NEIGHBORHOOD? YES NO OCCASIONALLY YES, DURING LOCKDOWN 7% 13% 20% 48% 6% 6% WHY DO YOU WALK WITHIN YOUR NEIGHBORHOOD? PRAYER EXERCISE SHOPPING VISITS TO REACH WORK TO REACH PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION 4% 13% 70% 13% DO YOU USE A BICYCLE? YES NO OCCASIONALLY YES, DURING LOCKDOWN 12% 12% 8% 4% 64% MODE OF TRANSPORATION CAR BICYCLE BUS TAXI WALKING 51 CATEGORIZING CHALLENGES FOR DISTRICT 10 URBAN PLANNING • • Lack of commercial services within the northern edges of the neighborhoods. • • Congestion around the commercial block at the center of Prince Hasan Street and insufficient parking. • • Lack of a nearby health center. • • Lack of amenities within public open spaces. MOBILITY • • Insufficient number of bus stops and a lack of seating and shading amenities at existing stops. • • Limited pedestrian mobility due to lack of proper shaded routes and sidewalk obstacles. • • Lack of safe routes for bicycles and improper detailing for drainage trenches causing safety hazards for bicyclists. ENVIRONMENT • • Improper disposal of waste causing the gathering of pests and rodents. • • Insufficient stormwater drainage and the formation of swamps within buffer zones and vacant lands. • • Lack of green picnic areas, trails, and playgrounds within public spaces and buffer zones. • • Delays in waste collection. COMMUNITY INCLUSION • • Pedestrian crossings and sidewalks do not take the needs of people with disabilities into consideration, curbs are too high and lack proper ramps for wheelchairs or any form of aid for the visually impaired. • • Buffer zones are unsafe due to lack of sufficient lighting. • • Lack of clear signage. 52 MAPPING COMMON DAILY ROUTES AND CHALLENGES BY RESIDENTS OF DISTRICT 10 All pedestrian crossing are unsafe and inaccessible for persons with disabilities. Intersection with Al-Farouk Highway is unsafe with frequent accidents. Small vendors and mini markets are prohibited within neighborhoods. Lack of safe routes for bicycles and unsuitable drainage trench details. Lack of a health center and community center Buffer zones feel unsafe and unutilized to allow people to enjoy the oudoors and excercise. Fires due to lack of safe designated barbecue locations. Formation of swamps that gather pests and rodents. Lack of shade along pedestrian routes makes it difficult to walk to services. Lack of shaded bus stops on Kuwait Street and limited amount of pedestrian crossings. District 10’s commercial block is insufficient and often causes traffic and parking congestions. Missing clear signage for road names and building numbers. Vacant lands are used as dumpsites for construction waste and trash. 53 CATEGORIZING CHALLENGES FOR DISTRICT 7 URBAN PLANNING • • Lack of main and subsidiary entrances to the neighborhood. • • Cars often use sidewalks as parking spaces. • • Narrow streets. • • There is no bakery or vegetable store. • • Dumping construction waste in empty plots. • • Monitoring the cleanliness and the lighting of internal streets. • • Lack of health care center and commercial markets. • • Lack of public school. • • Traffic congestion near the school due to the lack of entrances. • • Poor street lighting. MOBILITY • • Insufficient number of bus stops and lack of seating and shading amenities at existing stops. • • Lack of safe routes for bicycles and improper detailing for drainage trenches causing safety hazards for bicyclists. ENVIRONMENT • • Lack of mega shops. • • The need of public playgrounds and parks. • • Lack of parking spaces. • • Lack of places designated for families. • • A lot of stray dogs in area. COMMUNITY INCLUSION • • Pedestrian crossings and sidewalks do not take the needs of people with disabilities into consideration; curbs are too high and lack proper ramps for wheelchairs or any form of aid for the visually impaired. • • Lack of places for outdoor activities. • • Lack of clear signage. 54 MAPPING COMMON DAILY ROUTES AND CHALLENGES BY RESIDENTS OF DISTRICT 7 Lack of pedestrian pathways and narrow sidewalks. The need for public playgrounds. Lack of health care center. Lack of public school. Lack of bicycle lanes. Lack of public transportation. Lack of public green spaces. Lack of parking areas and traffic congestion near the school. Poor street lighting. 55 4.5 FRAMING CHALLENGES The following is a summary of overlapping challenges to be addressed based on neighborhood analysis and community input: Service Distribution - Lack of walkable access - Commercial nodes distribution - Healthcare services - Community centers for events Public Transportation Network - Inadequate number of stops - Lack of shading structures - Lack of clear signage Walkability - Sidewalk obstacles - Misplaced planters - Not enough crossings - Discontinued pedestrian paths Waste Management - No recycling facilities - Unsustainable disposal methods Energy Consumption - Lack of incorporation of energy efficient and renewable energy methods in building design. - Lack of infrastructure that utilizes renewable energy. Accessibilty for Persons with Disabilities - Inadequate detailing for crossings - Ramps at crossings do not follow standards - Sidewalk obstacles - No tactile paving for the visually impaired URBAN PLANNING Public Green Spaces - Unutilized green area plots - Lack of shading trees - Lack of shading canopies - Lack of park amenities - Lack of playgrounds - Lack of public athletic facilities - Need for nature trails MOBILITY Cycling - Lack of designated bicycle lanes - Inadequate details for trenches causing safety hazards for bicyclists - Lack of bicycle parking Reliance on Fossil Fuel Vehicles - Reliance on personal vehicles - Lack of incentives for sustainable modes of transport - Lack of infrastructure for electric vehicles ENVIRONMENT Urban Microclimate - Lack of urban greenery and shading trees along sidewalks - Increased urban heat due to vehicles’ CO 2 emmissions Stormwater Management - Lack of permeable surfaces - Lack of environmentally functional landscapes that help absorb stormwater. COMMUNITY INCLUSION Safety - Inadequate lighting in public spaces - Lack of clear signage for pedestrian safety 56 5. DESIGN& PLANNING SOLUTIONS 5.1 RECOMMENDATIONS 5.1.1 NEIGHBORHOOD PLANNING CONSIDERATIONS Enhance Access to Services Evenly distributed neighborhood nodes for essential services for commercial, greenspace, healthcare, community, or educational facilities should be provided. Neighborhood nodes should typically fall within a continuous pedestrian accessibility network as they should be easily accessible by foot, bicycle, car, or bus. Minimizing the travel distance to basic services promotes the use of zero energy transportation methods which reduce energy consumption and CO 2 emmissions within the neighborhoods. Public Open Space Various public space typologies within neighborhoods should be activated to offer oppotunities for recreation, physical exercise, social gatherings, and temporary community events. Public spaces should be accessible and suitable for a range of ages and abilities. The two focus neighborhoods provide opportunities for various typologies of open space that can be improved and activated differently such as paved plazas for social gatherings, central neighborhood parks for family gatherings and children play areas, and linear parks along buffer zones for nature outings and recreational activities. In addition to their social benefits, public open spaces can have impactful environmental benefits through improving air quality, enhancing microclimate conditions, and biodiversity. Re-claiming public spaces to include greenery and amenities. 58 5.1.2 ENHANCING SUSTAINABLE MOBILITY Walkability The ability to travel on foot to access basic services in the neighborhood, or simply for leisure, should be facilitated. Continious sidewalks of an appropriate width should be provided, with no obstacles. Safe, clearly marked pedestrian crossings should also be provided at appropriate intervals to allow for pedestrians to cross at these areas, rather than at random locations(which may pose a safety risk to them and to other road users). In addition to public services, the pedestrian network should also provide access to other modes, such as public transportation(safe pedestrian access to bus stops), cycling(bicycle rental/parking stations, if introduced in Aqaba), and also the private car(on-street and offstreet parking facilities). Improving the pedestrian environment in the two neighborhoods will encourage taking short trips by foot which, in turn, will have benefits in terms of reducing congestion levels, enhancing air quality, and improving the health and well being of residents. Cycling In addition to walking, other light non-motorized transport modes (micromobility) should be encouraged. There is a unique opportunity to promote cycling in Aqaba given the conditions described in Chapter 2 and the feedback from residents provided during the workshop. Cycling lanes have been proposed in the two neighborhoods as part of the design solutions. These lanes should be enforced and respected by pedestrians and car drivers in order to encourage the adoption of cycling. Appropriate parking locations for bicycles should also be provided. Cardactivated bicycle sharing stations are also proposed. As mentioned above for walkability, active mobility in general can offer substantial benefits in congestion reduction, air quality, and health and wellbeing of residents. 1m .8m 2m Minimum bicycle lane dimensions. 59 Electric Mobility Changes are required at the national level in Jordan to scale up the adoption of electric mobility; however, there are still actions that can be taken at the local level in Aqaba. The provision of public charging stations in some locations could encourage residents to purchase electric vehicles. Aqaba could also introduce a pilot passenger transport service that runs on electric vehicles(either a bus or a smaller vehicle). With climate change and the detrimental impact of fossil fuels on the environment, global mobility trends are shifting to electric vehicles both on the private and public transport sides. Jordan has seen a relatively high adoption of private electric vehicles but this has slowed down in recent years due to changing tax/customs regulations and limitations in the charging infrastructure. The opportunities for electrification and decarbonization of transport extend beyond passenger cars and buses into lighter modes (micromobility). Aqaba could serve as a pilot for the introduction of electric bikes or scooters at the city level. This study includes proposals for cycling lanes, which can be used not only by conventional bicycles, but also by electric lightweight vehicles. Public Transportation Jordan has been making notable and much-needed investments in improving the state of public transport. The country is in dire need of safe, affordable public transport services and Aqaba is no exception. There are measures that can be taken in the medium- and long-terms to improve the state of public transport in Aqaba. These will not be presented in this study. However, there are certain shorter-term measures that can be taken at the neighborhood level to improve access to public transport services. These include providing safe bus shelters and waiting areas, safe access to these bus stops(as described above under“Walkability”), and appropriate signage and bus maps to encourage the use of public transport where possible. Traffic Calming Encouraging active mobility(walking and cycling) should be coupled with measures that ensure the safety of all road users. Among these are traffic calming measures, which reduce the speed of vehicles by various means(hard infrastructure elements, speed limits, and stricter enforcement). Traffic calming is essential for the safety of pedestrians, cyclists, and also drivers, especially in a country that has long been dominated by private car transport. Re-designing streets with shaded sidewalks, protected bicycle lanes, and accessible crossings. 60 5.1.3 ADDRESSING ENVIRONMENTAL CHALLENGES Microclimate Adaptation Enhancing microclimate is key to enhancing walkability within neighborhoods. To date, a great number of scientific studies have evaluated the impact of different mitigation strategies towards the improvement of the urban thermal environment and its implicit effects. The most effective strategies include: urban greenery, use of cool materials, and water-based mitigation techniques such as sprinklers, ponds, and fountains. These methods will be further discussed below. Maximizing Urban Greenery Finding the maximum number of opportunities for the application of urban greenery within neighborhoods will have a major role in microclimate mitigation through evapotranspiration and shading of the adjacent ground and building surfaces by tree foliage. This contributes to lower amounts of solar energy absorbed and stored urban surfaces and, consequently, to lower convective and radiative heat fluxes. Apart from evaporative cooling and radiation management, urban greenery also highly enhances the aesthetics of the urban districts and contributes to pollutant, airflow, and noise control. In addition, shrubs planted within sunken rain gardens and bioswales provide a nature-based solution to manage storm water runoff, by supporting existing drainage infrastructure which reduces the risk of flash floods and surface water pollution. Opportunities to maximize urban greenery within neighborhoods include street canopy trees, shrubs, and trellises along pedestrian footpaths; densifying vegetation within parks; and the application of green roofs. Cool and Permeable Surface Materials Cool materials have been broadly examined as an adaption strategy towards the improvement of the microclimate of urban areas. The materials that are characterized as“cool” should absorb and store lower amounts of solar radiation, compared to conventional materials, so as to maintain reduced surface temperatures. The longwave radiation flux emitted towards the surrounding environment is thus considerably reduced; leading to lower ambient temperatures. Cool pavement surfaces can be achieved by different techniques: • • Changes in the solar reflectance(albedo) and infrared emittance. This category contains the so-called“highly reflective” and “thermochromic” pavements. • • Changes in heat storage of pavements. This category involves paving materials embedded with phase change materials(PCM). • • Changes in the evaporation rates. This cluster involves the porous, pervious, and water retaining pavements. Using porous and permeable materials such as bound gravel and interlocking tiles on pavements reduces stomwater runoff by allowing water to naturally drain into the ground, rendering it as a resource instead of waste. In addition, porous floors soak up rain water to the underlying layers of rock and soil, filtering it from pollutants before reaching nearby shores. Impermeable surfaces within neighborhoods such as asphalt and concrete pavers need to be replaced with alternative materials wherever possible. Surface areas where cool and permeable materials can be implemented include sidewalks, cul de sacs, paved plazas, parking locations, pedestrian footpaths and walking trails within green areas. 61 Enhancing Ecosystems and Biodiversity Urban biodiversity provides functioning ecosystems that supply oxygen, clean air and water, pollination of plants, pest control, wastewater treatment, and many ecosystem services. As cities grow in population and size, more natural areas disappear. Restoring nature and enhancing biodiversity is essential for making communities, native plants and wildlife species resilient to the climate crisis(Zari MP, 2018). Aqaba is home to many local and migrant bird species. Identifying natural areas, species to be protected, and other opportunities for ecosystem enhancement is a key step for protecting biodiversity in urban settings. In addition to natural land, opportunities could also include smaller interventions such as green roofs, trellises, and green walls. The two selected neighborhoods feature green buffer zones near highways and stormwater infrastructure that are currently unutilized and contain native trees and shrubs. By densifying existing native plant species and introducing bioswales and rain gardens, these buffer landscapes can perform vital environmental functions such as providing bird habitats, flood protection, filtering water runoff, improving air quality, and much more as mentioned above. Sustainable Waste Management Sustainable waste management is a key concept of the circular economy and offers many opportunities and benefits to the economy, the society, and the environment. Sustainable waste management involves collecting, sorting, treating, and recycling and when properly facilitated, provides a source of energy and resources. It therefore, creates jobs, improves waste management methods, and lessens the impact of human activities on the environment thereby improving air and water quality. It also reduces food wastage, keeps heavy environmental costs at bay, and prevents some human health conditions improving overall quality of life. Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy The way neighborhoods are designed have an impact on energy efficiency and consumption. On the one hand, residents behavior can also contribute to this goal by reducing the amount of energy consumed inside homes through adopting energy saving behaviors, ensuring proper insulation and using energy efficient appliances, etc. On the other hand, proper neighborhood planning also results in energy efficiency through improving pedestrian and cyclist infrastructure, providing access to public transit, designing climate responsive buildings, building a more compact development and increasing renewable energy supply, among other things. Increasing the amount of energy from renewable and low carbon technologies will help to make sure Aqaba has a secure energy supply, reduce greenhouse gas emissions to slow down climate change, and stimulate investment in new jobs and businesses. Re-designing pedestrian pathways with porous pavement, bioswales and shading trellises. 62 5.1.4 ENSURING COMMUNITY INCLUSION Access for People with Disabilities In all of the recommendations presented above, interventions should be taken such that they are accessible to persons with disabilities (mobility, visual, or hearing disabilities). Sidewalk ramps and tactile paving at intersections and crossings; wheelchair access on at least some public transport vehicles; audio announcements on bus stops; and clear signage using large fonts and appropriate color schemes are all relatively small measures that can go a long way in making the mobility system in Aqaba more inclusive. Gender Sensitive Design and Safety In all previous recommendations, special considerations should be taken into account to ensure that public spaces and mobility networks are safe for women and young girls. Ensuring safety for women in mobility networks improves women’s chances and access to employment and education opportunities, therefore enhancing their economic status. Considerations in gender sensitive design include (UN-Habitat et al., 2012): • • Easy access to and from the location, and easy movement within it. • • Good lighting so that users can see and be seen. • • Security cameras, if needed. • • Easy-to-read signs to help users find their way. • • Clear, well-kept paths where users can easily see each other. • • General visibility of the entire space, free from hiding places where a person could wait unseen. • • Inclusion of mixed uses – many places to hang out, walk, play, eat, exercise, etc. for diverse user groups at different times of day. • • Provisions for young children and the elderly(because women are often caretakers), e.g. this could mean low, wide sidewalks for strollers, wheelchairs, and walkers. • • Access to clean, secure, easily accessible toilet facilities in public spaces with dedicated areas for nursing and diaper changing. Participatory Activities and Community Responsibility Campaigns Adopting a participatory approach in planning public spaces is an important tool for understanding communities’ needs and expectations as direct stakeholders. Participatory design activities can give voices to marginalized groups to ensure that proposed designs are inclusive for women, girls, person with disabilities and elderly citizens. In addition, community members can have a role in sustaining public spaces through awareness and responsibility campaigns in topics such as recycling, plantation, safety, vandalism, and hygiene, etc. Community organizations that can take an active role in these campaigns include schools, clubs, civil society, and community-based organizations. All pedestrian crossings should include accessible ramps and tactile paving. 63 5.2 PILOT NEIGHBORHOOD A- DISTRICT 10 PROPOSED BICYCLE NETWORK SERVICE NODES 0 20 60 140 300m Two-way Bicycle Lane Proposed Bicycle Sharing Station Two-way bicycle lanes on one side of the road are introduced along the AlFarouq Highway, collector roads, and the main 20m-wide road that loops within the neighborhood and its main entrances. The maximum radius for blocks without proposed bicycle lanes is 150m. This layout was chosen to serve the majority of the neighborhood without changing car traffic direction on local roads and only requiring sidewalk adjustments on one side for main roads. 0 20 60 140 300m Mixed Use Area Healthcare Center A mixed use service node is proposed to encourage walking to services on the northwestern block of the neighborhood. A healthcare center is proposed within a central District 10 service plot on Prince Hasan Street. Additional public space amenities such as jogging trails, outdoor gyms, playgrounds, and space for athletic activities are proposed in existing green areas and buffer zones. 64 DISTRICT 10 - DESIGN AND PLANNING SOLUTIONS PROPOSED GREEN NETWORK PROPOSED PEDESTRIAN NETWORK 0 20 60 140 300m Urban Biodiversity Parks Shading Canopy Street Trees/Porous Pavement Bioswales and Trellis Shaded Pathways Sidewalks and pedestrian footpaths should be designed with a greater permeability to capture and slowly release stormwater into the ground using vegetation and/or porous pavement. In addition, vegetation along sidewalks and pedestrian paths can provide shade to improve walkability and enhance microclimatic conditions. Public green areas should be fully utilized to protect biodiversity and support various outdoor activities. Pedestrian Crossing Pedestrian Footpath Sidewalk Ensuring the continuity of safe pedestrian routes is a top priority. Crossings are proposed at street intersections and should align with existing pedestrian footpaths. Both crossings and footpaths should always be accessible to persons with disabilities. 65 DISTRICT 10 - DESIGN AND PLANNING SOLUTIONS PROPOSED STREET SECTIONS 40M WIDTH STREET 4.25 m 11 m 40 m street 9.5 m 8.5 m 2.5 4.25m 4.25 m 2 m 9 m 40 m street 9.5 m 8.5 m 2.5 4.25 m SIDEWALK ROAD MEDIAN ROAD PARKING SIDEWALK SIDEWALK BIKE LANE ROAD MEDIAN ROAD PARKING SIDEWALK EXISTING CONDITION - Three lanes in each direction. - Parallel parking on one side. - Wide sidewalks with shading trees and lush bogainvillea-covered fences. - Wide central median with palm trees and pennisetum shrubs. PROPOSED CONDITION - Three lanes in each direction. - Parallel parking on one side. - Two-way bicycle lane on one side(adjacent to planned linear park by ASEZA). 66 DISTRICT 10 - DESIGN AND PLANNING SOLUTIONS PROPOSED STREET SECTIONS 30M WIDTH STREET 30 m street 4.5 m 2.5m 5.5 m 5 m 5.5 m 2.5m 4.5 m 30 m street 4.5 m 2 m 2.5 m 5.5 m 3 m 5.5 m 2.5m 4.5 m SIDEWALK PARKING ROAD MEDIAN ROAD PARKING SIDEWALK SIDEWALK BIKE LANE PARKING ROAD MEDIAN ROAD PARKING SIDEWALK EXISTING CONDITION - Two lanes in each direction. - Parallel parking on both sides. - Wide sidewalks that lack consistent shading trees. - Central median with poinciana trees. PROPOSED CONDITION - Two lanes in each direction. - Parallel parking on both sides. - A consistent array of shading canopy street trees are proposed on sidewalks. - Two-way bicycle lane on one side(median width was slightly reduced to allow for bicycle lanes without narrowing down road width). 67 DISTRICT 10 - DESIGN AND PLANNING SOLUTIONS PROPOSED STREET SECTIONS 20M WIDTH STREET 20 m street 4.5 m 2.5m 6 m 2.5m 4.5 m 20 m street 2.5 m 2 m 2.5m 6 m 2.5m 4.5 m SIDEWALK PARKING ROAD PARKING SIDEWALK SIDEWALK BIKE LANE PARKING ROAD PARKING SIDEWALK EXISTING CONDITION - One lane in each direction. - Parallel parking on both sides. - Wide sidewalks that lack proper sidewalk shading trees. Choice of unsuitable plant species(such as palm trees) and centering planter locations is often obstructive to pedestrian movement without providing shade. PROPOSED CONDITION - One lane in each direction. - Parallel parking on both sides. - Two-way bicycle lane added on one side within width of existing sidewalk. - Planting appropriate canopy trees at the outer edge of sidewalks only, in order to provide shade for sidewalks and bicycle lanes without obstructing pedestrian movement. 68 DISTRICT 10 - DESIGN AND PLANNING SOLUTIONS PROPOSED STREET SECTIONS 12-14M WIDTH STREET 12-14 m street 2-3 m 2.5m 3.4 m 2.5m 2-3 m 12-14 m street 2-3 m 2.5m 3.7 m 2.3m 2-3 m SIDEWALK PARKING ROAD PARKING SIDEWALK SIDEWALK PARKING ROAD PARKING SIDEWALK EXISTING CONDITION - One lane in each direction but mostly obstructed by parking; leaving one lane only. - Parallel parking on both sides. - Wide sidewalks that lack consistent shading trees. PROPOSED CONDITION - Planting appropriate canopy trees at the outer edge of sidewalks only, in order to provide shade for sidewalks without obstructing pedestrian movement. - No bicycle lanes were proposed due to narrow street width and need for parallel parking. 69 DISTRICT 10 - CLOSE-UP A The commercial block on Prince Hasan Street is a busy node that invites a lot of vehicular and pedestrian traffic. Gatherings were observed on the service road across the street indicating the need for a public plaza. A paved plaza is proposed with seating and shading trees. The proposal also focuses on re-configuring the parking layout at the commercial block around a linear service lane with porous paving. This will allow for the green area shown in land use regulations at the center of the block to be reclaimed. 70 DISTRICT 10 - CLOSE-UP A Introduce a charging station for electric vehicles. Service road and extended linear parking to reduce congestion near commercial block with porous interlock paving. All crossings should be continuous with accessible ramps and tactile paving. Service road re-configured as a multi-purpose plaza to cater for observed residents behavior in the evening. The plaza is provided with porous interlock paving, sidewalk benches, and trees. Prince Has an St. Shaded pedestrian pathways with bougainvillea trellises, bioswales, and porous pavement. Green area shown in land use regulations within commercial block is reclaimed and utilized. Shaded bus stops. Bicycle sharing station. Consistent planting of shading canopy trees along outer edges of sidewalks to enhance walkability and microclimate. 71 DISTRICT 10 - CLOSE-UP B The generous buffer zone along the Al-Farouk Highway offers an opportunity for creating rich green areas with native species to promote biodiversity and become an integral part of a green network that ties into the planned linear across the street. The buffer zone can include porous walking trails and shaded pedestrian pathways connecting the neighborhoods to the linear park. This close-up view focuses on the intersection of the AlFarouk Highway and Prince Hasan Street as an example. 72 DISTRICT 10 - CLOSE-UP B Green public spaces with play areas and amenities for athletic activities. Two-way bicycle lane provided to promote energy saving methods of transportation. Densified native vegetation to create natural habitats that support biovdiversity. Sunken bioswales and rain gardens planted with native shrubs. l-Farouk St. A Prince Has an St. All crossings should be continuous with accessible ramps and tactile paving. Pedestrian nature trails for walking or jogging with porous materials and lighting. Shaded bus stops. Bicycle sharing station. Shaded pedestrian pathways introduced to connect cul de sacs to the linear park across the buffer zone. 73 5.3 PILOT NEIGHBORHOOD B- DISTRICT 7 PROPOSED STREET DIRECTION PROPOSED ENTRANCES 0 20 60 140 300m 0 20 60 140 300m All 12m streets were converted from two-way direction to one-way direction. Existing Entrances Proposed Entrances An additional entrance is proposed on the Jordan Valley Highway which will reduce traffic congestion on the existing entrances. 74 King Faysal St. King Faysal St. DISTRICT 7 - DESIGN AND PLANNING SOLUTIONS EXISTING INTERSECTION AND DEAD END Basman St. port St. Air PROPOSED ENTRANCE CONFIGURATION Basman St. port St. Air Valley Highway Jordan The map above shows the existing condition at the intersection between Airport Street and Basman Street near a local street dead end within the neighborhood. The land plots adjacent to the dead end from the South side are currently owned by ASEZA. Valley Highway Jordan A new connection is suggested on Basman Street to connect the Jordan Valley Highway with District 7, creating a new entrance to the neighborhood away from schools and congested areas. A new location for a roundabout is proposed as shown on the map; at the intersection of Basman Street and King Faysal Street, connecting to the current dead end street. This proposal is suggested based on a previous study that was conducted in 2017(Assessment of Traffic on the Main Roads of Aqaba, Tender No. 35/A/2016. Aqaba/Aqaba Development Corporation). 75 DISTRICT 7 - DESIGN AND PLANNING SOLUTIONS PROPOSED BICYCLE NETWORK PROPOSED SERVICES 0 20 60 140 300m One-way Bicycle Lane Two-way Bicycle Lane Bicycle Sharing Station A bicycle network in the neighborhood is suggested with one-way and twoway lanes according to the street section. In addition, automated bicycle rental and sharing stations are proposed in different locations to encourage bicycle usage. 0 20 60 140 300m The existing services locations are sufficient and the available shops are suitable for the inhabitants without additions. The two proposed parks shown on the map should be utilized and properly designed to be used by residents(Based on ASEZA’S land use plan). 76 DISTRICT 7 - DESIGN AND PLANNING SOLUTIONS PROPOSED PEDESTRIAN NETWORK In order to have a sufficient pedestrian network, the following interventions are proposed: • Tiled sidewalks around all streets whether the plots around them are utilized or not. • Rehabilitation of pedestrian pathways. • Pedestrian crossings must be implemented. • The needs of people with disabilities must be implemented where appropriate Sidewalk Pedestrian Footpath Pedestrian Crossing 0 20 60 140 300m 77 DISTRICT 7 - DESIGN AND PLANNING SOLUTIONS PROPOSED STREET SECTIONS AL-HUSSEIN BIN ALI STREET The existing section is suitable for the road’s function as an arterial. No changes are proposed. 78 DISTRICT 7 - DESIGN AND PLANNING SOLUTIONS PEDESTRIAN PATHWAY SECTIONS 4M WIDE PEDESTRIAN PATHWAY EXISTING CONDITION - Pathways lack shade. - Pathway tiling surface is a non-permeable cement block. - Pathways sometimes lack accessible ramps. PROPOSED CONDITION Proposed design of pedestrian pathways with porous pavement, bioswales, and planted trees on the sides that creates natural shading. This should encourage walkability, improve microclimatic conditions, and perform other environmental functions. 79 DISTRICT 7 - DESIGN AND PLANNING SOLUTIONS PROPOSED STREET SECTIONS 12M WIDTH STREET One-way Street EXISTING CONDITION PROPOSED CONDITION A - One lane in each direction(two-way traffic) but the street is mostly obstructed by parking, leaving one lane only. - Parallel parking on both sides. - Sidewalks either lack planting or contain planters at the center of the sidewalk with unsuitable plant species that obstruct pedestrian movement. - One-way traffic direction. - Parallel parking on one side. - One-way bicycle lane added on one side. - Planting appropriate canopy trees at the outer edge of sidewalks. 80 DISTRICT 7 - DESIGN AND PLANNING SOLUTIONS PROPOSED STREET SECTIONS 12M WIDTH STREET PROPOSED CONDITION B - One-way traffic direction. - One-way bicycle lane added on both sides. - Planting appropriate canopy trees at the outer edge of sidewalks. PROPOSED CONDITION C - One-way traffic direction. - Parallel parking on both sides. - Planting appropriate canopy trees at the outer edge of sidewalks. 81 DISTRICT 7 - DESIGN AND PLANNING SOLUTIONS PROPOSED STREET SECTIONS 20M WIDTH STREET EXISTING CONDITION - One lane in each direction. - Parallel parking on both sides. - Wide sidewalks that lack shading trees. PROPOSED CONDITION - One lane in each direction. - Parallel parking on both sides. - One-way bicycle lanes added on both sides within width of existing sidewalk. - Planting appropriate canopy trees at the outer edge of sidewalks. 82 DISTRICT 7 - DESIGN AND PLANNING SOLUTIONS 3D VIEW OF PROPOSAL 20M WIDTH STREET 83 DISTRICT 7 - DESIGN AND PLANNING SOLUTIONS PROPOSED STREET SECTIONS BASM EX A I N ST S IN TR G EET EXISTING CONDITION PROPOSED CONDITION 84 DISTRICT 7 - DESIGN AND PLANNING SOLUTIONS PROPOSED STREET SECTIONS JORDAN VALLEY HIGHWAY AND WADI T STORMWATER CHANNEL EXISTING CONDITION PROPOSED CONDITION 85 DISTRICT 7 - CLOSE-UP A BASMAN STREET WALKWAY The proposed design of the pedestrian path and green area along Basman Street provides potential opportunities to encourage active travel and increase the amenity of the space. Planting these green areas with appropriate trees, such as canopy trees and native plants, would promote biodiversity and enhance air quality and temperature while providing natural shading for pedestrians. 86 DISTRICT 7 - CLOSE-UP B JORDAN VALLEY HIGHWAY AND WADI T STORMWATER CHANNEL Wadi T, which flows through central east Aqaba, originates in the Edom Mountains east of the city. The flow of stormwater running through this valley has been directed to an open channel that forms part of the stormwater drainage network which was established in Aqaba protect the city after recent flooding events. This channel passes through district 7, parallel to Jordan Valley highway. Based on the Final Flood Protection Master Plan done by USAID in 2011(USAID, 2011); The channel needs constant maintenance, as excess stormwater sometimes leads to overbank flooding that enters the urban development adjacent to the channel. This issue was also reported by the residents during the workshop held in August 2021 for this study. It is critical to reanalyze the design and efficiency of the channel and provide better solutions. It is necessary to maintain the safe buffer zone(20m - 30m) around the water channel by prohibiting any building activity within that area. The proposed design suggests intensifying the landscape within this buffer zone by planting suitable shrubs and trees that preserve the soil. Introducing landscape berms with stabilized slopes using gravel or other porous materials can have a vital impact in protecting nearby plots. Berms form a barrier that blocks the overflow of excess stormwater in the case of a flash flood. In addition to reducing flood risk, cultivating the buffer zone with appropriate vegetation can enhance biodiversity, improve air quality and microclimatic conditions, as well as provide beautiful views. 87 DISTRICT 7 - CLOSE-UP C PARK ON BASMAN STREET INTERSECTION The corner of District 7- where Basman Street meets Al-Shareef Al-Husayn Bin Ali Street- is classified as a green area in land use plans but is currently vacant. The proposed design of a public park would offer neighborhood residents opportunities for recreational activities, physical exercise, and social gatherings and mark an entrance to the Basman Street walkway. BASMAN STREET AL-SHR EEF AL-H USA YN BIN ALI STR EET 88 DISTRICT 7 - CLOSE-UP D PARK WITHIN THE NEIGHBORHOOD CENTRAL BLOCK A proposed park in the center of the neighborhood that is accessible by all residents would be a great asset to the general environment and for social interaction. In addition, the park would support local shops surrounding it and create potential opportunities for various activities. MOSQUES SHOPS 89 DISTRICT 7 - 3D VIEWS OF PROPOSAL Proposal for Basman Street. Park on Basman Street intersection. Park on Basman Street intersection. Park within the neighborhood’s central block. 90 6. FUTURE WORK 6.1 TRANSITION EXPERIMENTS Tactical Urbanism and Transition Experiments are approaches to community development using short-term, low-cost, and scalable projects intended to catalyze long-term change. Tactical Urbanism experiments can be an effective tool for testing new solutions to improve neighborhood resilience by: • • Fostering neighborhood interaction; • • Encouraging and promoting non-motorized transportation; • • Encouraging pedestrian safety and activity; • • Reimagining the potential of city streets and land use; • • Supporting local businesses. Different examples of interventions can be applied in Aqaba’s neighborhoods to engage residents in specifically addressed topics: Intersection Safety Improvements Paint and markings can be used on some streets and intersections to widen sidewalks and create more safe open areas for pedestrians. Pop-up Bicycle Lanes Temporary lanes marked by cones or painting to encourage and increase demand on cycling which could lead to permanent solutions. Pedestrian crossing(Jersey City, USA). Parklets Convert curbside parking spaces into vibrant community space. Pavement to Plaza Convert an existing parking space or street into an open space and encourage pop-up local shops and vibrant community activities. This allows people to temporarily reclaim streets and parking areas. Collective Planting Activities Raise awareness in regards to the importance of urban greenery and choosing the right type of species in accordance to appropriate planting palettes. Engaging community members in planting activities and urban farming can also enhance their sense of ownership and belonging. Intersection safety intervention(India). 92 Pop-up bicycle lane(Sydney, Australia). Parklets(Texas, USA). Street turned into temporary plaza(Vancouver, Canada). Collective planting activities(New York City, USA). 93 6.2 SCALING UP Resilience ensures that development progress is not lost by the first natural or man-made disaster, and it limits the impact of shocks and stresses on people, infrastructure, and processes. Scaling up successful solutions is the main challenge for a city’s resilience transition. Sustainable practices must scale up within sectors and scale out across geographies and industries. Upscaling increases the impact of environmental change for obvious reasons. The more broadly sustainability measures are applied, the greater their impact. However, upscaling requires coalitions of public, private, and civil society actors who align their motivations. Pathways to upscaling may involve leveraging a dominant player’s market power; integrating successful initiatives into public policy; or reinforcing government-led change with private efforts. Various actors agree to collaborate to take advantage of their complementary capabilities. In working towards sustainability and ensuring the city’s resilience, it is essential to assess Aqaba’s strategies and plans. It is important to integrate the neighborhood level recommendations(provided in Chapter 5) into wider and larger scale strategies that combine the whole city to maximize impact. Local participation and the creation of strategies and processes encourages sustainable living. The activities that we can reach and the life that we can develop are all dependent, in part, on the built environment that we shape. The adverse impacts of growth- in economic, environmental, and social terms- are ruining the quality of life in our cities and our global climate. For instance, although many individuals may enjoy travelling by car, or aspire to own a car, there are huge problems if a large number of people choose to do this. A city with too many cars, motorcycles, or polluting vehicles can be very difficult to live within. Innovation, replication opportunities, and lessons learned should be explicitly considered in program development management and review- at the city of Aqaba level- so that results achieved from the interventions proposed in this study at the neighborhood level can be sustained over the long-term. Scaling-up strategies are an essential aspect of ensuring better coverage and impact of the smaller scale development innovations proposed at the neighborhood level. Together, with emphasis on sustainable results, this will not just mean designing successful projects to operate on a larger scale at the Aqaba city level but also strengthening- in parallel- national, regional, and sub-regional policies, skills base, financing strategies, and institutional capacities. It is essential to elaborate on scaling-up in connection with specific areas of engagement, including to test and scale-up public-private initiatives that can increase employment and livelihoods opportunities using production technologies that are sustainable and markets that are inclusive. These initiatives include scaling-up inclusive marketbased solutions to achieving city wide affordable and clean energy access; especially to off-grid sources of renewable energy and to finance the scaling-up of promising ideas. UNDP’s Guidance Note(UNDP, 2013) on scaling-up, posted in January 2013, provides an excellent introduction and high-level guidance for how to apply a scaling-up approach in UNDP programs. In connection with, and based on, the Guidance Note, UNDP also issued a two-page pamphlet for use by UNDP country teams entitled“Program Design Questions for Scaling-Up”. This pamphlet contains a definition of scaling-up for the UNDP, a set of useful guiding questions for program design, and a helpful list of references. Based on this approach, the study developed a set of initiatives and interventions stemming from the resilient city pillars adopted throughout this study. 94 URBAN PLANNING MOBILITY ENVIRONMENT COMMUNITY INCLUSION • • Deliver sustainable and best practice greening opportunities for parks and sidewalks. • • Provide regulations and landscape palettes that promote bio-diversity and native eco-systems within green buffer zones. • • Incentivize application of green building codes. • • Protect natural areas and buffer zones from urbanization through strict regulations, especially safety zones near drainage infrastructure for their vital role in mitigating flood risk as environmentally functional landscapes. • • Forming a transition team at ASEZA to oversee and support the work towards sustainability and resilience. • • Reduce travel distances and catchment areas for major activity nodes. • • Increase the operational efficiency and infrastructure of public transport. • • Design for safety and for active transport. • • Enhance subsidies and establish sufficient charging infrastructure to incentivize the public to adopt electric vehicles. • • Create a team responsible for an Aqaba climate change portfolio. • • Network and collaborate with international agencies on climate change. • • Identify and implement energy saving solutions for neighborhoods(buildings, streets, public spaces, etc.). • • Increase use of solar power PV cells. • • Green building and energy efficiency retrofitting. • • Deliver rainwater harvesting plan at city level. • • Implement greywater recycling and reuse at city level. • • Implement organic waste composting at city level. • • Implement waste separation at source and enable recycling activities on the city level. • • Support the development of public private partnerships. • • Increase public participation in greening initiatives. • • Develop public awareness campaigns relating to green building solutions and technologies. • • Develop codes and regulations for integrating accessibility guidelines for persons with disabilities in public spaces, sidewalks, and streets. • • Ensure women’s security by designing open public areas with visibility, lighting, and CCTV camera systems. Recognize sexual harassment and gender-based violence as criminal offences and develop reliable reporting mechanisms. • • Empower women in public and transport sectors by reducing entrance barriers to employment for women at all levels(drivers, managers, entrepreneurs, decisionmakers, etc.). 95 6.3 THE AVOID-SHIFT-IMPROVE FRAMEWORK Many attempts have been made in recent years to manage Jordan’s cities development in a more sustainable manner. Despite the fact that there is a continually expanding selection of very promising initiatives and projects; good practice remains unaccomplished. Jordanian cities face significant challenges in policy, planning, governance, and implementation. Development plans are frequently closer to wishlists than to feasible, budgeted, and prioritized strategies. Policies are frequently left unimplemented or only partially implemented. When investment does occur, little is known about impacts relative to aspirations. Projects are rarely evaluated to discover if they were effective and implementation lessons are rarely learnt. Projects are prone to time and cost overruns with little builtin resilience and adaptation to uncertain futures. Technical advice is sometimes ignored in political decisions and participation in decisionmaking is typically quite minimal. There is insufficient knowledge transfer, benchmarking of practice, risk analysis and management, and performance evaluation. As a result, sustainable behaviors are not being widely adopted. Aqaba has a great opportunity to turn this around and regain its competitive edge, minimize its environmental impacts, become a more attractive city to live and work, and develop strong senses of character and identity. Mobility, environment, and urbanization are all critical facets of Aqaba’s future livability and resilience. The imperative of climate change adds a greater impetus for action, with the window of opportunity closing more each year. It is crucial to integrate these aspects into master plans and climate change actionables. Therefore, planners should develop, implement, and communicate comprehensive sustainable urban mobility, environment, and urban planning plans and appoint respective advisors in ASEZA. It is important to develop Aqaba to reflect local needs and aspirations - specific to local aspirations but consistent with global sustainability objectives. A successful climate change strategy in transport requires the adoption of a comprehensive and coherent approach centered on humans instead of cars. This is where the Avoid-Shift-Improve(ASI) Framework can help. This approach- known as ASI from Avoid/Reduce, Shift/Maintain, Improve - seeks to achieve significant GHG emission reductions, reduced energy consumption, and less congestion with the final objective to create more livable cities. The ASI Framework has three key dimensions and different modes make contributions across the dimensions. There is 1) Avoid measures which avoid or reduce the need to travel, for example, or the production of unnecessary quantities of waste. 2- Shift measures which seek to shift to more energy efficient and environmentally acceptable modes. And 3- Improve measures which take the residual effect(past avoid and shift measures) and seek to improve the efficiency through sustainable technologies. Accordingly, any remaining vehicular travel is made efficient by low emissions or being alternatively fueled(GIZ-SUTP, 2019). 96 No Travel Activity No desire or need to travel Active Transport Walking, Cycling Public Motorized Transport Public Transport(bus, rail) AVOID/ REDUCE Avoid or reduce travel or the need to travel Enhancing electronic services, facilitating the establishment of home-based businesses, and providing flexibility to work from home can help avoid making certain trips. Furthermore, by implementing an integrated land use planning policy and fine-grained urban fabric(high density and mixed land use areas), travel distances can be reduced. Issues to be considered include the following: • • Trend towards online shopping. • • Transit oriented development(TOD) - development concentration around transport hubs and vice versa. • • Expanding transportation network into neighborhoods and suburbs. • • Well-linked and permeable new developments. SHIFT Shift to more energy efficient modes Short travel distances can be more easily undertaken by active transport or public transport. By increasing the operational efficiency and infrastructure of public transport, as well as safety, design and infrastructure for active transport, the individual may regard these modes as more convenient for the daily trips. Interventions to be considered include the following: • • Travel Demand Management(TDM) • • Car parking restrictions and Speed limits • • Availability, affordability, and quality of public transport options • • New pedestrian links to create a network of convenient routes • • better footways(paving, landscaping, lighting, street furniture) • • Streets and public areas that create interest for pedestrians(building frontages, signs, and advertisements scaled for the pedestrian rather than the vehicle) • • The provision of a fully segregated cycle network alongside facilities within the main road and footpath network • • Bike parking and storage facilities that are secure and conveniently located. Individual Motorized Transport Car, Taxi, Motorcycle IMPROVE Improve efficiency through vehicle technology In the medium-/long-term the individual may consider reducing car size or using vehicles with improved energy and carbon efficiency. Innovations in transport information systems, priority schemes for public transport(BRT/LRT), electrical bicycles, or car sharing will further improve the transport sector. Subsidies, an appropriate, widely available, charging infrastructure, and financial incentives can encourage people to use the electric version of a vehicle. Interventions to be considered include the following: • • Charging stations and infrastructure for clean fuels. • • Tax/customs regulations. • • Vehicle sharing options. 97 6.4 CONCLUSION RESILIENT AQABA: IMPROVED LOCAL ECONOMY, LIVELIHOODS, AND TOURISM Achieving sustainable and resilient development in Aqaba contributes to boosting tourism, the local economy, and livelihoods in a sustainable manner and enhances residents’ overall quality of life. Tourism is one of Jordan’s fastest growing industries and an important source of foreign exchange and employment while being closely linked to the social, economic, and environmental well-being of Aqaba. Maritime or ocean-related tourism(as well as coastal tourism) are vital sectors of the economy in Aqaba. As a resort and a port city, with tourism a major industry, Aqaba is undergoing major expansion with new luxury neighborhoods, attractions, and hotels opening frequently. As such, a resilient Aqaba is essential towards achieving sustainable tourism which can be defined as“tourism that takes full account of its current and future economic, social, and environmental impacts; addressing the needs of visitors, the industry, the environment, and host communities.” The importance of sustainable tourism is also highlighted in SDG Target 12b, which aims to“develop and implement tools to monitor sustainable development impacts for sustainable tourism that creates jobs and promotes local culture and products.” In the context of this study, achieving sustainable mobility promotes sustainable tourism in Aqaba. Utilizing public transport or active travel allows the traveler to immerse themselves in the beauty of Aqaba and experience authentic local culture and heritage without the pressures of operating their own vehicle. Improving accessibility will benefit local shops and boost Aqaba’s attractiveness and competitiveness. It also enhances the city’s resilience rather than experiencing great stresses on the natural and social environment during high seasons of tourism. In conclusion, this study“Aqaba: A Resilient City Through Its Neighborhoods” in its totality- the designed interventions on the neighborhood level as well as the scaling-up initiatives presented make up the backbone of potential support to sustainable tourism activities and essential capacity-building activities. It is these activities that can promote environmental awareness; conserve and protect the environment; create respect for wildlife, flora, biodiversity, ecosystems and cultural diversity; and improve the welfare and livelihoods of Aqaba’s local communities by supporting their local economies and both the human and natural environment of the city as a whole. 98 7. REFERENCES REFERENCES UNISDR, How To Make Cities More Resilient: A Handbook For Local Government Leaders- A Contribution to the Global Campaign 20102020 Making, 2007 ..................................................................................... The Rockefeller Foundation| Arup, 2014. City Resilience Framework The Rockefeller Foundation| Arup ..................................................................................... UNDP, 2020. COVID 19 Impact on Households in Jordan ..................................................................................... Zureiqat, H., Lattouf, F., Ghannam, T., Aldhami, R., Ureiqat, B., Tahhan, S., Suboh, N., Sweidan, F., 2020. Neighbourhoods of Amman- A/E Business Council& The Regional Energy and Climate Project in the Middle East and North Africa(MENA) of Friedrich-Ebert ..................................................................................... ASEZA.(2001). Aqaba Special Economic Zone Authority. https://aseza. jo/Pages/viewpage.aspx?pageID=1 ..................................................................................... Department of Statistics.(2020). Directorate of Family and Population ‫ Surveys Estimated Population of the Kingdom by Governorate, Locality, ‬ Sex, and Households, 2020 ‬ .................................................................................... MP ASEZA.(2001). Aqaba Special Economic Zone Master Plan, Design Guidelines ..................................................................................... Oxford Business Group.(2018). Jordan’s growing coastal city Aqaba continues to attract investment| Jordan 2018| Oxford Business Group. The Report: Jordan 2018. https://oxfordbusinessgroup.com/overview/ growing-coastal-city-continues-attract-investment-forward-momentum Aqaba Development Corporation, n.d. Assessment of Traffic on the Main Roads of Aqaba, Tender No. 35/A/2016. Aqaba ..................................................................................... Attari, A., Schiffer, R., Hegazy, M., Zureiqat, H., Semaan, R., Abu-Eisheh, S., 2020. The Mobility Transition in the MENA Region Comparative Policy Perspectives. Amman ..................................................................................... Jordan Strategy Forum, 2018. Vehicle Ownership in Jordan| Jordan Strategy Forum(2018)[WWW Document]. Jordan Strategy Forum. URL http://www.jsf.org/en/content/vehicle-ownership-jordan ..................................................................................... Tarawneh, D., Zeyad, A., Schiffer, R., 2020. Urban Mobility and Spatial Justice of Amman: A Brief Handbook on Urban Intersectionality ..................................................................................... CES-MED, 2012. Jordan Sustainable Energy and Climate Action Plan for Aqaba Special Economic Zone Authority ..................................................................................... Department of Environment. The Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan. NATIONAL ENVIRONMENT STRATEGY FOR JORDAN: A Resource Book of Information and Guidelines for Action, Ministry of Municipal& Rural Affairs& the Environment, Department of Environment, IUCN The World Conservation Union ..................................................................................... EDAMA, 2018. Policy Paper Solid Waste Collection Scheme in Aqaba EDAMA Association for Energy, Water, and Environment ..................................................................................... Farhan, Y., Anaba, O., 2016. Flash Flood Risk Estimation of Wadi Yutum (Southern Jordan) Watershed Using GIS Based Morphometric Analysis and Remote Sensing Techniques. Open Journal of Modern Hydrology 06, 79–100. https://doi.org/10.4236/ojmh.2016.62008 100 Odat, S., Abu-Allaban, M., AL-Trawneh, B., 2018. Study on the Impact of Weather on Air Quality at Aqaba Nature Environment and Pollution Technology, An International Quarterly Scientific Journal, Open Access 17, 359–366 ..................................................................................... UNDP, 2015. State of the Coast Environment, Report for Aqaba- UNDP ..................................................................................... ASEZA, 2021. Neighbourhoods Development Department[WWW Document]. URL https://aseza.jo/Pages/viewpage.aspx?pageID=80 ..................................................................................... Department of Statistics, 2020. Jordan Statistical Yearbook 2020 – Department of Statistics[WWW Document]. URL http://dosweb.dos. gov.jo/products/jordan-statistical-yearbook-2020/ ..................................................................................... Department of Statistics, 2019. Jordan Statistical Yearbook 2019 – Department of Statistics[WWW Document]. URL http://dosweb.dos. gov.jo/products/statistical-year_book2019/ ..................................................................................... Department of Statistics, 2018. Jordan Statistical Yearbook 2018 – Department of Statistics ..................................................................................... DRIFT.(2014). Roorda, C., Wittmayer, J., Henneman, P, Steenbergen, F. van, Frantzeskaki, N., Loorbach, D., Transition Management in the Urban Context: Guidance Manual. DRIFT, Erasmus University Rotterdam, Rotterdam, 2014. www.drift.eur.nl ..................................................................................... USAID.(2011). Improved Drainage and Flood Control for the Aqaba Special Economic Zone Authority(ASEZA) Volume 1: Final Flood Protection Master Plan for Wadi Yutum and Adjacent Coastal Wadis. Zari, M. P.(2018). The Importance of Urban Biodiversity – An Ecosystem Services Approach. Biodiversity International Journal, 2(4), 357–360. https://doi.org/10.15406/bij.2018.02.00087 ..................................................................................... UN-HABITAT, Adebanjo, M., Khosla, P., Snyder, V.,& UN-Habitat Gender Coordination and Support Unit.(2012). GENDER ISSUE GUIDE URBAN PLANNING AND DESIGN ..................................................................................... UNDP.(2013). Guidance Note: Scaling Up Development Programmes ..................................................................................... GIZ-SUTP, TUMI, Bongardt, D., Stiller, L., Swart, A.,& Wagner, A.(2019). ASI_TUMI_SUTP_iNUA_April-2019 ..................................................................................... 101 The Regional Energy and Climate Project in the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) of Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung has Funded, commissioned, edited, and reviewed this study. Published by A/E Business Council. Year 2021 Not for sale. All Rights Reserved. No Part of this publication may be printed, reproduced, or utilized in any form or by any means without prior written permission from publishers. The views and opinions expressed in this publication are solely those of the original author. He does not necessarily represent those of the FriedrichEbert-Stiftung or the editor. Responsible: Sarah Hepp Head of the Regional Climate and Energy Project MENA Contact: amman@fes.de Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung Amman Office P.O. Box 941876 Amman 11194- Jordan info@aeb-council.org A/E Business Council Amman P.O. Box 930786 Amman 11193- Jordan ISBN NO.: 978-9923-9893-1-9