Review 
[Rezension von: Carl von Clausewitz, Vom Kriege / Hew Strachan, 2008]
Place and Date of Creation
Turn right 90°Turn left 90°
  
  
  
  
  
 
Download single image
 

Norbert Eliass theory of the civilizing process may be too lengthy for readers who are more interested in understanding the usa . Casual readers will surely miss a central story line: The book can be read like a series of essays, with topics ranging from»American Manners« through»Violence and Aggression« and»In­tegration Struggles« to»America and Humanity as a Whole.« They represent ap­proaches to the same social process from different perspectives, which can some­times give the impression of redundancy. Nevertheless, Mennells book provides useful insights even for those familiar with the history of the United States and its relations with the rest of the world. In particular, the comparison between the United States up until the First World War with the European Union as it is today(in the chapter»Integration Strug­gles«) brings to the surface some striking similarities. The(by now perhaps di­minishing) prestige of the us federal government and presidency, the power of the United States armed forces and of the us dollar today make it easy to over­look that just a century ago they seemed to be almost irrelevant in global inter­national relations. The two World Wars played a major role in the United States global ascent and fostered the functional and habitual integration of the people of its states into the federal union. The challenge for the European Civilizing Process and furthermore for the Global Civilizing Process then seems to be, if one follows Mennells account, to install proper social regulations and a unifying feeling of identity without a major war or other kind of catastrophe. To meet this challenge, new perspectives are needed, to which Stephen Mennells book about the American civilizing process could contribute. Michael Fischer, Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung, Bonn HEW STRACHAN: Carl von Clausewitz, Vom Kriege München 2008 Deutscher Taschenbuch Verlag, 160 S. W enige Zitate sind so bekannt wie dieses:»Der Krieg ist eine bloße Fortset­zung der Politik mit anderen Mitteln.« Der Mann, von dem es stammt, Carl von Clausewitz, kann mit einigem Recht als einer der bedeutendsten, wenn nicht sogar als bedeutendster Theoretiker des Krieges bezeichnet werden. Seit dem Erscheinen 1834 hat sich sein Hauptwerk»Vom Kriege« zu einer der wichtigs­ten Schriften über Krieg und Strategie überhaupt entwickelt. Es zählt nicht nur zur Standardlektüre an allen wichtigen Militärakademien, gern bedienen sich seit Neuestem auch Unternehmensberater und Marketingexperten aus dem Ideen­fundus des Preußen. ipg 3/2008 Rezensionen/Book Reviews 151