d) The differences in the level of political-administrative professionalism are also serious. Only in a few countries do we find trade unions with a consolidated and efficient working apparatus. Such unions are able to make and implement strategic decisions with the assistance of a qualified political and scientific staff. In Germany, for example, the unions have a professional group of full-time functionaries who increasingly serve their organizations like modem service enterprises. e) Of paramount importance for trade union policy is representation at plant level. The extreme cases can best be compared with the shape of a triangle: In Germany, the works council is an independent body enjoying many information and co-determination rights with which the trade unions carry out a unified programme of worker representation according to a specific division of labour; from the micro- to the meso- to the macro-economic levels. In other countries, such as Great Britain and Italy, the representative organs at factory level are the basic units of the trade unions and they have negotiation and strike authority. These are not institutions whose existence is guaranteed by national law, nor do they have legally recognized co-determination rights; they rely exclusively on trade union resources. As a result their effectiveness is extremely dependent on the shifting power relations which change with the general political climate and overall economic situation. In a third group of countries.with mostly weak trade unions(France and Spain) one can find mixtures of relatively undeveloped forms of both the works council model and the delegate model. f) In the area of collective bargaining the spectrum of agreements ranges from those which are overwhelmingly concluded at the company level(as in Great Britain),. to the sectoral contracts signed with one or another employers' association representing the enterprises in a particular branch of industry(as in Germany), to the countries(such as Italy) in which the main trade union organizations are dominant and the governments are heavily involved in the bargaining process. g) That there is just as much variety in terms of the trade unions' right to strike and the employers' lock-out rights as there is with arbitration procedures need only be mentioned in passing. To summarize this section, it can be seen that there is signficant variation concerning the degree of institutionalization and legal rights as well as the degree of centralization, representation and professionalism. We find both protected and unprotected systems of representation, flexible and rigid rules and regulations, robust and temperamental structures, coordinated and fragmented representation, innovative and conservative trade unions. These relationships make it clear that all efforts to harmonize the nationally distinctive trade union and social cultures with a leveling model of uniformity can only be counter-productive. The trade unions will have to learn how to forge an intelligent combination of features that can both compensate for weaknesses and exploit strengths. Such a process of reciprocal learning will be promoted by the fact that there is no national trade union and bargaining system which is superior to all others in all matters of importance. With respect to institutionally supported stability, there are indeed a number of structural advantages to be found in the West and North European model. On the other hand, features of equal value can be found in other countries when one focuses on political innovativeness and connections with the rank and file. In establishing a capable policy suitable for all of Europe, the trade unions face essentially the same problems as all other participants: how to prevent the diversity of structures and interests from leading to chaotic and highly competitive fragmentation? And the reverse: how can diversity be transformed into cooperative gains which benefit all through the combination of complementary qualities?
Druckschrift
The case for social democracy as the trade union perspective in Europe
Einzelbild herunterladen
verfügbare Breiten